Originally posted by eaebiakuya
http://s779.photobucket.com/user/R-O-G/media/FBKevinAns.jpg.html
Originally posted by The Sorrow
Thanks. Seems like he may have intended it to be Hulk initially but it didn't end up that way, "Hulk" is also red. That scene wouldn't have been out of place from his fight with Ross in Hulk #6.
Kevin Grevioux said it was The Hulk. Even if it isn't the intention is what the writer actually believe so in the end it doesn't matter.
Originally posted by themadsurfer
Kevin Grevioux said it was The Hulk. Even if it isn't the intention is what the writer actually believe so in the end it doesn't matter.
Just saying if you wish to highlight aspects of Hulk v Thor history there are much clearer and relevant examples than one panel of a fight between Thor and a creature which may or may not have been the Hulk.
Originally posted by The Sorrow
He said it was originally intended to be the Hulk, but it does matter because that isn't what we ended up with on panel.Just saying if you wish to highlight aspects of Hulk v Thor history there are much clearer and relevant examples than one panel of a fight between Thor and a creature which may or may not have been the Hulk.
You are in a respect thread saying a lot of bullshit. Kevin said that Thor was supposed to be in his classic costume end of story. If there was a way to rewrite the comic he would.
I not going to argue with the Thor fanboys over a non-canon comic. And they say Pak was wanking Hulk up. I thought this was supposed to be in a respect thread for Thor. Here's a blurry scan for Thor. Far from being so slow
Originally posted by kakuzu
http://i93.photobucket.com/albums/l46/gaarakaku/fighting%20pics/Thor/Journey_in_to_mystery099-13-crop.jpg
Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
I not going to argue with the Thor fanboys over a non-canon comic. And they say Pak was wanking Hulk up. I thought this was supposed to be in a respect thread for Thor. Here's a blurry scan for Thor. Far from being so slow
Unfortunately, true. Some Thor fanboys go to extremes to downplay Hulk and/or show Thor in favorable light: they'll use out of continuity books, what-ifs, etc. I don't doubt they'll start using fan fiction someday... ridiculous.
Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
I not going to argue with the Thor fanboys over a non-canon comic. And they say Pak was wanking Hulk up. I thought this was supposed to be in a respect thread for Thor. Here's a blurry scan for Thor. Far from being so slow
If you want to see Thor moving fast then just read Thor 337. He engages Skuttlebutt at multiples of light speed.
I agree though, no need to over analyze feats. Thor has lots of them and frankly would beat the Hulk in most any given scenario assuming he uses all his powers.
If you want to read a great Hulk-Thor fight then read Thor 389 I believe where he fights the Hulk without his hammer. Bottom line, Thor gives as good as he gets but loses in the end. Hulk pretty much admits that it would be a different story if Thor uses his hammer.
Originally posted by Warrior Madness
Unfortunately, true. Some Thor fanboys go to extremes to downplay Hulk and/or show Thor in favorable light: they'll use out of continuity books, what-ifs, etc. I don't doubt they'll start using fan fiction someday... ridiculous.
Worst post in this Thor respect thread so far, facepalm for you.
You talk like Hulk fanboys doesn't do that at all, like the What-if where WWH was stalemating OdinforceThor or "Let the battle begin" or some making an argument that a savage hulk can beat a Warrior-madness Thor because it was show in a comic where Thor wouldn't survive a nuke!!
That comic shows what an specific writer called Kevin think about Thor WITH HAMMER vs Hulk, there are some interviews where he says that Hulk can only match Thor's strength at his best(angriest).
Lee also believe in that but naturally there are some who doesn't believe that.
Tom brevoort:
Agreed, and a question(s) for the fans.
Does Thor know any actual magic? Any evidence of him ever casting spells or invoking powers ala Dr. Strange?
Below is a synopsis of what Dr. Strange does:
Master of the Mystic Arts, Doctor Strange is one of the most powerful sorcerers in the world. Dr. Strange uses mystical energy invoked upon by spells/incantations or by the power of divine beings to manipulate forces of the universe including projection of mystic energy as bolts, slashes, binds, shields, or a scattered array of energy appearing like electricity, manipulating matter and various energies (physical or spiritual) even transmutation of matter, controlling the elements, opening or sealing mystical portals to other realms, teleportation or dimensional travel, reality warping and control over dimension, seeing through or casting illusions, invisibility and intangibility through astral projection, vast mental powers such as telepathy and telekinesis, communication with the dead and spiritual entities, seeing the future or past, manipulating dreams, removing spirits or placing them back into bodies, summoning supernatural beings, or using the powers of supernatural items.
A lot of that, not all, but a lot of that seems like things Thor can do.
So, do you consider him an actual magic user in a sorcerous sense?
Originally posted by riv6672
Agreed, and a question(s) for the fans.Does Thor know any actual magic? Any evidence of him ever casting spells or invoking powers ala Dr. Strange?
Below is a synopsis of what Dr. Strange does:A lot of that, not all, but a lot of that seems like things Thor can do.
So, do you consider him an actual magic user in a sorcerous sense?
I think Thor can only cast some illusions and talk to the dead.
I'm looking at things like, Thor's called on his father, a divine being.
Dr. Strange has his Eye of Agamotto, Thor has Mjolnir.
Thor can project mystic energy as bolts, shields, or a scattered array of energy appearing like electricity, manipulating matter and various energies, even transmutation of matter, controlling the elements, opening or sealing mystical portals to other realms, teleportation or dimensional travel.
Isnt he then doing the same things as Dr. Strange?
I know its a stretch but, its something i've always wondered, and, i thought this might distract from the last bout of conversation...
