Which list or lists do you agree with the most?

Started by Prep-Man1 pages
Prep-Man Senior Member

Which list or lists do you agree with the most?

I found a nice link of top 10 games of all time being made by different sources and whatnot. Anyway, which list do you like the most? The one that best suites you, if any.

http://www.filibustercartoons.com/games.htm

Lacan Restricted

This one:

1. Star Ocean: Till the End of Time
2. Tales of Phantasia
3. Final Fantasy VII
4. Xenogears
5. Golden Sun
6. Final Fantasy IX
7. Dragon Quest VIII
8. Metal Gear Solid 4
9. Metal Gear Solid 2
10. Metal Gear Solid 3

AsbestosFlaygon The Original One

Nickolas' Weighted Rankings seems to be the most agreeable amongst the lists. At least, for me.

ArtificialGlory God-Emperor of Eternity

None, but this one comes the closest:

GameSpy.com (2001)

1 DOOM id / GT Interactive 1993
2 Half-Life Valve / Sierra 1998
3 Warcraft 2 Blizzard 1995
4 Civilization Microprose 1991
5 Quake id / GT Interactive 1996
6 Diablo Blizzard 1996
7 Ultima IV: Quest of the Avatar Origin 1985
8 Ultima Underworld: The Stygian Abyss Origin / Blue Sky
9 StarCraft Blizzard 1998
10 Legend of Zelda Nintendo 1986

Bardock42 Junior Member

Originally posted by ArtificialGlory
None, but this one comes the closest:

GameSpy.com (2001)

1 DOOM id / GT Interactive 1993
2 Half-Life Valve / Sierra 1998
3 Warcraft 2 Blizzard 1995
4 Civilization Microprose 1991
5 Quake id / GT Interactive 1996
6 Diablo Blizzard 1996
7 Ultima IV: Quest of the Avatar Origin 1985
8 Ultima Underworld: The Stygian Abyss Origin / Blue Sky
9 StarCraft Blizzard 1998
10 Legend of Zelda Nintendo 1986

That is a pretty good list for the time.

Obviously Gothic was out by then so it should be disqualified, as should all lists afterwards not featuring it.

ArtificialGlory God-Emperor of Eternity

Originally posted by Bardock42
That is a pretty good list for the time.

Obviously Gothic was out by then so it should be disqualified, as should all lists afterwards not featuring it.

Well, now that you said it, it doesn't have HoMM3 in it either. So that's double disqualified.

One Free Man Restricted

eh, what kind of list has everyone's favorite game in it?

No End N Site Saikyo Pharaoh Sol Radguy

NONE OF THEM, all of the lists are bull shit! Where the hell is 3rd Strike on any of the lists? And it should be number 1.

Bardock42 Junior Member
Originally posted by One Free Man
eh, what kind of list has everyone's favorite game in it?

I don't know, a list of every game perhaps.

dadudemon Senior Member

I would say the list from game rankings is fairly accurate for me:

Here mine are, from that list, in no particular order:

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.
Super Metroid
GoldenEye 007
Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars
Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island
Perfect Dark
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
Starcraft
Super Smash Brothers Brawl
Warcraft III

Ridley_Prime Smug icon slayer

Originally posted by One Free Man
eh, what kind of list has everyone's favorite game in it?

Biased ones.

Originally posted by No End N Site
NONE OF THEM, all of the lists are bull shit! Where the hell is 3rd Strike on any of the lists? And it should be number 1.

Oh, whine, whine, whine.

One Free Man Restricted

Originally posted by Bardock42
I don't know, a list of every game perhaps.
No particular order, but here's my list:
http://www.giantbomb.com/games/?sort=release_date&filter_type=theme&filter_value=6

jaden101 Restricted

I'd probably have a mix of the IGN readers poll 2008 and the Age newspaper/LiveWire 2005

In no order

Ocarina of Time
A link to the past
Gran Turismo 4
Shenmue II
San Andreas
Metal Gear Solid
Perfect Dark.
Resident evil
Guitar Hero

Yes that's only 9...I'm a rebel.

Digi Forum Leader

PC Gamer had an incarnation of their "50 Best" back in maybe '98 that had Dark Forces II at #1. That was my best ever list, with the rest of it being pretty damn good too.

Scythe The Goat
Originally posted by jaden101
Yes that's only 9...I'm a rebel.

Ah no you di'in't.