James Cameron's work might be Racist?

Started by queeq9 pages

Someone dug up the R-word to sound politically correct?

Is there a relationship between CGI and the perception of racism? (after all, it turned up after TPM as well.)

Originally posted by Wild Shadow
would ppl say that if will smith had the lead?

Well, wasn't it a black man and a jew who saved the world in Indipendance Day ?

But these were Smurfs. Doesn't that count?

Avatar is overhype...

If the Smurfs are as anti-semitic as suggested, then no, they dont need to count.

Oh... now they're anti-semitic... Some people sure have WAAAAYYY to much time on their hands.

and according to wiki, Gargamel is a jewish steriotype.

i'm offended that the alien smurfs were blue when they should have bn brown as it was an obvious refernce to native americans and indigenous ppl of the americas..

f$%@ black ppl being mad they have no claim here shuff off only ppl i see having the right to be mad is true native americans from south and north

Smurfs are communists govern by the wizard-communist Papa smurf.

Love those crazy Dutchs...

Everything is racist. If you can't win something, that's because it's racist, if something is working better than you'd like it to, that's because it is racist. If you don't do anything with your life, it's because it's racist. If things are not going your way, it is because it is racist.

If you have failed at life, it is because everything is racist all the time at every point and every place, everywhere.

Anyone telling you any different is clearly a racist who is trying to get away with racism.

Originally posted by lil bitchiness
Everything is racist. If you can't win something, that's because it's racist, if something is working better than you'd like it to, that's because it is racist.
If you have failed at life, it is because everything is racist all the time at every point and every place, everywhere.

AHA!

With that knowledge, I can create the GUT!

Originally posted by lil bitchiness
Everything is racist. If you can't win something, that's because it's racist, if something is working better than you'd like it to, that's because it is racist.
If you have failed at life, it is because everything is racist all the time at every point and every place, everywhere.

qfft

right, because racial inequity has no historical source or legacy and effects the lives of nobody today

Originally posted by inimalist
right, because the racial inequity people are complaining about in avater has no historical source or legacy and effects the lives of nobody today
fixed.

Originally posted by inimalist
right, because racial inequity has no historical source or legacy and effects the lives of nobody today
btw what is an "inimalist"?

Originally posted by One Free Man
fixed.

it in fact does. The image of the white person saving less developed people from fights they could never win is very common, especially in stories generating from the time of colonialism. It hits a cord with people who have, as recently as the 80s, had their children taken from them to be educated in Christian schools "for their own good".

Obviously Cameron wasn't trying to be racist. However, the point is that he has adopted a very common story telling device that has been used to oppress people, some of whom are still alive. Some discussion about what, if any, effect that might have and the personal experiences that come from being on the losing end of that narrative is probably warranted.

Less warrented is dissmissively insulting people who don't agree with you, especially if you don't know the origins of modern Hollywood cliches.

Originally posted by One Free Man
btw what is an "inimalist"?

me?

the "M" is decadent and superfulous

Originally posted by WickedDynamite
Smurfs are communists govern by the wizard-communist Papa smurf.

Love those crazy Dutchs...

Weren't they Belgian? Like Poirot? 😕

Originally posted by inimalist
it in fact does. The image of the white person saving less developed people from fights they could never win is very common, especially in stories generating from the time of colonialism.
well, the bad guys were all white, it wasn't like they were portraying the blue people as lesser. It's the same story as Pocahontas. I wouldn't consider that racist, as it is based on historical fact.

Originally posted by One Free Man
well, the bad guys were all white, it wasn't like they were portraying the blue people as lesser. It's the same story as Pocahontas. I wouldn't consider that racist, as it is based on historical fact.

ok

however, there are people who don't agree with you. They see the idea as insulting, because it promotes the idea that without the intervention of "white man", people would be left to die out. Inherent in this is the idea that people want to be helped and that the help is benevolent, or rather, this is seen as irrelevant. The lesser is in the interpretation:

"We are weak alone, but here comes whitey to save the day"

Pocahontas, the movie, was largely inaccurate and faced some of the same criticism, iirc (I was young, and imho Native issues get more play in Canada)

I personally think a better criticism is to say that Cameron was unimaginative as far as the script was concerned, but there are people who interpret it in a racial way. Its like the video games thing though. You don't have to agree that it is racist, just appreciate that there is that connection and maybe pay some respect to it. People certainly shouldn't censor themselves, but they should also not just be passive recipiants of culture.

Originally posted by Wild Shadow
would ppl say that if will smith had the lead?
they did in hancock so either way some how or another no matter if the hero is white or black somwhere along the line its gonna be racist for someone cause nothing satisfies anyone anymore really.