2nd Round Redraft Thread

Started by -K-M-8 pages
Originally posted by leonidas
you're not really canadian, are you?

Spanish 🙁

Si.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
the team lounge is the problem

Talisman could have shrunk it or put it in his pouch for the time being. That's easy to deal with. Regardless its banned, so no big deal and we don't have BRB anymore.

Originally posted by -K-M-
Spanish 🙁

Si.

Fcking traitor....😠 No wonder why our VW Golfs sucked ass up here for the longest time, its because of people like you.

trading is officially closed, right?

Originally posted by -K-M-
Talisman could have shrunk it or put it in his pouch for the time being. That's easy to deal with. Regardless its banned, so no big deal and we don't have BRB anymore.
your team would have been gibbed once it materialized in the lounge the instant your team did though.

but yeah, beta ray's gone anyway

I don’t really care if Wonder Women’s Gear puts her over the top, or not. The point is, its not standard equipment. And we have an only “Standard Equipment” ruling.

Wonder Women w/ Full Gear is the same character with out it. The key difference is that you are dressing up your comments, to loophole your way into gaining “Base Items“.

Originally posted by "Id"
Wonder Women w/ Full Gear is the same character with out it.
Not in the context of tourney drafting. If this was the same character, we wouldn't be having this dispute. There's clearly a difference between the two drafts (hence your bitching), and there stands to be no logical reason why we can't use the character in the context presented in this tourney.

The character we've drafted exists.
The character we've drafted has appearances.
The character we've drafted has feats.
The character we've drafted has a power set that can be accurately gauged and that has been ruled to be within the power limits set for this tourney.

Why can't we use her?

Oh yeah. Because there's a more standard version of the character.

Wut?

Anyways, Batdude has told me that she's allowed and that his decision is final. I'm sure you've got all sorts of inanity to post though, so have at it, and I'll see you in the match tomorrow.

Isn't the matches on tuesday now?

Originally posted by -K-M-
Isn't the matches on tuesday now?
I know I asked for a postponed draft date, but since the ruling was revoked, I assumed we'd be proceeding forward as planned.

Dunno though. I doubt it's a big deal if people need to wait one day.

Either way, I intend on writing up our stuff tonight. srug

I would be too, but my partners is unavaliable (think its 3am there)

Sleep deprivation is no excuse.

I agree, sleeping and blinking is for the weak.

Let me ignore Smurphs tantrum bullshit, and address what matter.

The character we've drafted exists. - But of course its Wonder Women.
The character we've drafted has appearances. - Wonder Women is a vary poplar DC Character.
The character we've drafted has feats. - She does have a dedicated respect thread.
The character we've drafted has a power set that can be accurately gauged and that has been ruled to be within the power limits set for this tourney. Wonder Women is certainly well within, limits caps.

Why can't we use her? Wonder Women is not the problem. Its you passing her base equipment, as standard gear because in your own little mind you wish to believe it’s a different version of the same character.

But since you are in the mood of making questions.

Where is the equipment stored?
Where is this equipment located now?
Whey does she not equip her gear more often?

Originally posted by "Id"
Let me ignore Smurphs tantrum bullshit, and address what matter.
Cool. Feel free to address this then:

joel says: (5:30:15 PM)
so... are you making the Diana ruling now or after this round?
Steve says: (5:37:27 PM)
It's ok.
joel says: (5:38:15 PM)
sweet. thanks._
Steve says: (5:42:11 PM)
I'm not backing down on this ruling either.

Steve = Batdude.

I'll just follow your lead and ignore the "tantrum bullshit", as you put it.

Her gear was all mentioned or shown explicitly in the Secret Files. She's donned the armor enough times to ensure it's not a plot device item, same with the gauntlets, sword, sandals, etc. It's essentially the same as the Iron Man analogy used earlier. She's not breaching the power cap, and pretty much everyone else is fine with this draft pick.

Personally, I have no problem with drafting WW with equipment... I just want to know that that same precedent will be applicable for all characters one might draft.

Drafting's closed and the matches are on as scheduled, I presume.

Originally posted by "Id"
Let me ignore Smurphs tantrum bullshit, and address what matter.

[b]The character we've drafted exists. - But of course its Wonder Women.
The character we've drafted has appearances. - Wonder Women is a vary poplar DC Character.
The character we've drafted has feats. - She does have a dedicated respect thread.
The character we've drafted has a power set that can be accurately gauged and that has been ruled to be within the power limits set for this tourney. Wonder Women is certainly well within, limits caps.

Why can't we use her? Wonder Women is not the problem. Its you passing her base equipment, as standard gear because in your own little mind you wish to believe it’s a different version of the same character.

But since you are in the mood of making questions.

Where is the equipment stored?
Where is this equipment located now?
Whey does she not equip her gear more often? [/B]

Is there going to be a updated draft list?

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Drafting's closed and the matches are on as scheduled, I presume.

😆

K, so I just sent my write-up in to Steve. Assuming he doesn't give us something ridiculous as a battle field, that should cover it.

ours was sent in last night as well. could it be matches will actually BOTH start on time!? shock