Thor/Beta Ray Bill vs Wonder Woman/Supergirl/Power Girl

Started by Enyalus3 pages

Originally posted by h1a8
That is why he took some very powerful magic of late with any damage.

Examples?

Originally posted by Enyalus
Examples?

Trust me when I say this, you wont get not one example and the example that he give, its going to be inaccurate.

hmm.. someones post is starting to sound a lot like H1, vampguy and all his other alias...

pokey

Superman not having a magic weakness is absurd and contradicts his history...

not just from vampire teeths...but vampire holds as well... punches too....

Captain marvel charging his hand and ko'ing supes in one hit...
atlas manhandling supes b/c he himself is a magical being..

being cut by mystic wpns without any force being applied on it but just normal momentum.... etc etc..

Originally posted by Enyalus
Examples?

Blaze

Also WW is another as she is made of magic and clay.

Originally posted by h1a8
Blaze

Also WW is another as she is made of magic and clay.


Lady Blaze? That wasn't recent at all. Much more recently, General Lane used magic-based lasers to take down Superman AND Supergirl.

And WW doesn't even qualify as a magical being. Unlike, say, Captain Marvel...who in fact has two-shotted Superman and attributed it to his magical weakness.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
I don't think Magic should have a Kryptonite effect on Superman. Shooting him in the foot with a magic bullet shouldn't be an instant KO or Kill, rather it should effect him just as a normal bullet effects a normal human. IMO they should remove the magic weakness, there are a lot more characters just as powerful as Superman with fewer weaknesses that still manage to have interesting stories. In fact Superman's MOST interesting stories are usually stories where he doesn't encounter any of his weaknesses but is challenged nonetheless.
It depends on ho wthe writer handles it really but it's still a weakness to varying degrees.

Originally posted by quanchi112
It depends on ho wthe writer handles it really but it's still a weakness to varying degrees.

only to some writers, though.

Originally posted by -Pr-
only to some writers, though.
That's why I put to varying degrees. Depends on the writer. Not a huge deal to busiek but it is to jurgens.

Originally posted by quanchi112
That's why I put to varying degrees. Depends on the writer. Not a huge deal to busiek but it is to jurgens.

it's just that jurgens hasn't written superman since before his upgrades...

Team 1