Most Un-Original Comic Characters....?

Started by roughrider2 pages

I don't think coming up with female versions of male characters (at the same company) is necessarily copying or unoriginal. Just trying a different direction.

Now, Midnighter of The Authority - he's a Batman clone who just embraces all the wink-wink-nudge-nudge homoerotic subtext of the 1950's-60's Bat family comics (the editors were really naive then, weren't they?) Him and Apollo, it's just playing out the whole "Yes, Kirk & Spock are gay!" fanatsy. 🙄

Originally posted by roughrider
I don't think coming up with female versions of male characters (at the same company) is necessarily copying or unoriginal. Just trying a different direction.

Now, Midnighter of The Authority - he's a Batman clone who just embraces all the wink-wink-nudge-nudge homoerotic subtext of the 1950's-60's Bat family comics (the editors were really naive then, weren't they?) Him and Apollo, it's just playing out the whole "Yes, Kirk & Spock are gay!" fanatsy. 🙄

See, here's the problem with that statement: MNer and Apollo were created deliberately as a dark parody of Superman and Batman. Heck, the entire Authority was created as a loose, more mercenary, clone of the JLA. There's a difference between intended copying and laziness.

And of course, they've all since become layered characters in their own right. The MN/Apollo relationship takes a back seat these days though.

Blockbuster - Hulk rip off.

Originally posted by Digi
See, here's the problem with that statement: MNer and Apollo were created deliberately as a dark parody of Superman and Batman. Heck, the entire Authority was created as a loose, more mercenary, clone of the JLA. There's a difference between intended copying and laziness.

And of course, they've all since become layered characters in their own right. The MN/Apollo relationship takes a back seat these days though.

Agreed.

Which is why it's important to establish from the outset of this thread that being unoriginal is not necessarily a bad thing 🙂

Originally posted by Warlord
I was talking about: spider-woman, arachne, spider-girl, crimson spider, ben reily etc...

What about Iron Man's rogues gallery? Half of them are just guys in pirated/reverse engineered versions of his suit.

A lot of Marvel Characters...

Originally posted by WickedDynamite
A lot of Marvel Characters...

You're biased, WD. 😉

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing

^ We have a winner.

Originally posted by roughrider I'll submit Mongul - he's a less interesting copy of Thanos.

Didn't Mongul come before Thanos?

Originally posted by Endless Mike
Didn't Mongul come before Thanos?

Nope. Jim Starlin created Thanos, and admitted he was trying to copy him at DC when he co-created Mongul.