Hal and Kyle vs Thor and Beta Ray

Started by Carver9_is_gay2 pages

Either Hal or Kyle would solo

Thor just got his ass kicked by Osbournes pathetic Initiative and had trouble with Taskmaster

BRB barely defeated Iron Man

Originally posted by Prep-Man
When has Hal's ring been absorbed before the 24 hr period? Who drained him of all his energy? Because the real limitation is Hal's imagination. I could easily say Hal can drain Thor's attacks as well.

from the top of my head I remember Kyle's ring drained in Avengers/JLA crossover.
Hal could drain Thor's energy attacks but Thor has much more than energy attacks for this fight while all Lantern's attacks are energy based

Originally posted by Carver9_is_gay
Either Hal or Kyle would solo

Thor just got his ass kicked by Osbournes pathetic Initiative and had trouble with Taskmaster

BRB barely defeated Iron Man

Kyle was KOed by prometheous and welcome back for the 436th time

Originally posted by Warlord
from the top of my head I remember Kyle's ring drained in Avengers/JLA crossover.
Hal could drain Thor's energy attacks but Thor has much more than energy attacks for this fight while all Lantern's attacks are energy based

Not all of Hal's attacks would be energy based. He's reflected powerful energy attacks before, so if Thor would to attack this way, he'd just reflect it back at Thor and Thor would then reflect it back at Hal. Kinda like a video game. 😉

Hal could mess with his soul, freeze time, matter manipulation, or just plain clobber him like he did with Superman. Basing some of these feats, Pre-Crisis, of course.

facepalm2

Originally posted by Warlord
Kyle was KOed by prometheous and welcome back for the 436th time
Prometheus would defeat Thor as well

Originally posted by Prep-Man
Basing some of these feats, Pre-Crisis, of course.
Stop.

Originally posted by Prep-Man
Not all of Hal's attacks would be energy based. He's reflected powerful energy attacks before, so if Thor would to attack this way, he'd just reflect it back at Thor and Thor would then reflect it back at Hal. Kinda like a video game. 😉

Hal could mess with his soul, freeze time, matter manipulation, or just plain clobber him like he did with Superman. Basing some of these feats, Pre-Crisis, of course.

hmmm...pre crisis feats...ok back then Hal could do just anything. Which I haven't seen him do for a very long time (soul stealing etc...)
Let's not forget that back in the day Thor was doing stuff like that too.
My point is that hal's ring has an energy limmit while thor's hammer has been shown so far to be able to absorb almost any ammount of energy.
So in this theoretical fight, taking into account that we have seen rings drained before, i see Thor winning. we can just agree to dissagree of course...😉

Originally posted by Carver9_is_gay
Prometheus would defeat Thor as well

why use prometheous...robin could do it as well

Originally posted by Warlord
hmmm...pre crisis feats...ok back then Hal could do just anything. Which I haven't seen him do for a very long time (soul stealing etc...)
Let's not forget that back in the day Thor was doing stuff like that too.
My point is that hal's ring has an energy limmit while thor's hammer has been shown so far to be able to absorb almost any ammount of energy.
So in this theoretical fight, taking into account that we have seen rings drained before, i see Thor winning. we can just agree to dissagree of course...😉

Who do you think wins? PC Hal or Thor?

any construct that hal makes is partly will based and energy based.. so thor's strength combined with repeated blows and a magic hammer might seem to be an advantage especially if we add exotic abilities that thor will unleash when he sees certain tactics being ineffective

generaly I'd give any PC character the win.
They could do ridiculous stuff back then
complete invulnerability, planet juggling, etc...

The ring can do just about anything as well. If we're talking about exotic abilities.

Originally posted by Warlord
generaly I'd give any PC character the win.
They could do ridiculous stuff back then
complete invulnerability, planet juggling, etc...

Kyle has done similar crazy crap. Probably MORE so than Hal nowadays.

Although, Hal and John absorbed the Parallax entitiy.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Mjolnir and Stormbreaker FTW.