AOTC Dooku vs. Zhannah

AOTC Dooku vs. Rule of two Zannah

1. Force TK
2. lightsaber skills
3. force power
4. who wins over all

Korriban fighting over a sith holocron who would win both have acces to any weapons or accessories they choose.

1. Unfortunately Zannah doesn't display anything close to what she should logically be able to do in ROT. As an untrained child she displays faaaar superior feats than her older self and maybe even Dooku, disintergrating a hand, levitation, and protecting herself from the Force bomb, which no-one else could do except Bane. If we allow the logic that she'd have only increased in power since then then she probably wins. However what we actually se is one use of teh Force and it blows. She gets tired after one freaking spell. While it states that its a tiring spell, thats really lame for someone supposedly on her level of potential. She should have been written like a mini-Bane. Does she? Nope.

2. I don't think Dooku has the strength to brake through her defences, though he may have the skills. Toss up.

3. See 1.

4. ROT Zannah? I'd say she's about equal to Dooku, logically. Going by actual showings he might edge her out though.

Originally posted by Nephthys
1. Unfortunately Zannah doesn't display anything close to what she should logically be able to do in ROT. As an untrained child she displays faar superior feats than her older self and maybe even Dooku, disintergrating a hand, levitation, and protecting herself from the Force bomb, which no-one else could do except Bane. If we allow the logic that she'd have only increased in power since then then she probably wins
.

Originally posted by gollumizer
didn't she disintegrate the hand in rule of two? I may be messed up but I thought that was when she challenged him at the end....

disintegrated her friend's hand in POD.

she used a spell to take out Bane's hand in DOE.

Originally posted by mattatom
No she did that in PoD to her childhood friend.

didn't she disintegrate the hand in rule of two? I may be messed up but I thought that was when she challenged him at the end....

Yeah, but it isn't a real feat we can use in fights becuase she did it instinctively, so it isn't quantifiable. Logically she should have gained control of that power by ROT. The darkside has been known to make you faster at learning for one thing. But she doesn't display anything on the same level of power after that. Her older self is reaaally lame in ROT. I liked her younger self quite a bit, but in the second half of ROT she was a total pussy. Banes obviously a really shitty teacher.

Please someone tell me she got better in DOE.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Yeah, but it isn't a real feat we can use in fights becuase she did it instinctively. Logically she should have gained control of that power by ROT. The darkside has been known to make you faster at learning for one thing. But she doesn't display anything on the same level of power after that. Her older self is reaaally lame in ROT. I liked her younger self quite a bit, but in the second half of ROT she was a total pussy. Banes obviously a really shitty teacher.

In POD he told her to get of the planet herself, I understand it was a test but come on she was like what? 12 at the most? I don't even think Palpatine was that bad, look at the end of the Mustafar fight he didn't go "oh you didn't beat Obi Wan sorry" and walk off, he gave him an entirely new body. so yes I think its safe to say he is an extremely shitty teacher

P.S. the lesson where he kills her pet was rather good though.

Yeah I get the impression he was more interested in teaching her to get into a mindset rather than actually expanding her abilities. Which as we see in the end he totally succeeded in. Her plan at the end is completely bad-ass. I may have been overly harsh earlier.

no I think you were on the nose, the reason I pitted these two off is because up to ROT they're pretty much equal. btw have you read the new book LOE or something like that?

I think Zannah has this: Pending RN's information about Zannah's force spell only being possible on the planet in which she used it.

Originally posted by truejedi
I think Zannah has this: Pending RN's information about Zannah's force spell only being possible on the planet in which she used it.

Plus this is Rule of Two Zannah. She can't do that thing yet.

Point taken