Thor vs Silver Surfer with twists.

Originally posted by cdtm
Any official word on Surfers base strength?

I'm thinking Thor wins the second, but loses the first.. Even without amping, Surfer still has the overall better durability.

Solely his base strength and no Power Cosmic amping at all involved? I'd say at the edge of Class 100's.

Amping Silver Surfer is going to defeat Warrior Madness Thor in a brawl? Ridiculous. Unamped Thor would beat down Norrin in a brawl.

Originally posted by lawest9
This is a hand to hand combat using only natural strength reflexes and durability.

First scenario is the surfer from planet Hulk restrained from using his PC against the physical prowess of classic Thor wlo mjolnir.

second scenario is warrior madness Thor against SS whose strength is augmented by the PC.

Both fights are bloodlusted, Who wins?

PC-amped Surfer is a wild card: there's no arguable way to gauge what this actually means (2x? 10x? 100x?). So I really don't know.

Thor stomps on Norrin till he shits silver pudding.

Originally posted by lawest9
This is a hand to hand combat using only natural strength reflexes and durability.

First scenario is the surfer from planet Hulk restrained from using his PC against the physical prowess of classic Thor wlo mjolnir.

second scenario is warrior madness Thor against SS whose strength is augmented by the PC.

Both fights are bloodlusted, Who wins?

Thor 7/10
Thor 10/10

Thor 6/10

Thor 10/10

Originally posted by Blanket
Now you know how it feels reading your posts. 🙂

Surfer is a pretty much shit in h2h

Originally posted by Mindship
Frankly, I was amazed at how well Surfer handled himself in Planet Hulk (and a rather sedate Surfer at that). If he'd been bloodlusted? I can see Hulk and crew laying bloodied at his toeless feet. So against classic Thor, I'm giving this to Soarin' Norrin, especially given his superior durability.

PC-amped Surfer is a wild card: there's no arguable way to gauge what this actually means (2x? 10x? 100x?). So I really don't know.

And what exactly did he do in Planet Hulk that supports the opinion that Norrin somehow takes Thor in a hand to hand battle? If anything, it supports the opinion that despite his so called durability, he'd get the shit beaten out of him in a brawl by Thor.

Lmao. Non amped Norrin taking Classic Thor in a brawl. Hilarious.

Thor has shown that he can take silver surfer out with relative ease. surfer has admitted (while the surfer was amped by loki) that he still couldnt beat thor.

thor wins all battles if he wants 2 in both scenarios...

I don't see how Surfer can take Thor in melee, let alone Warrior's Madness Thor.