black spidey.. no, not what you think..

Originally posted by Mindset
If they make a movie with him being black, it is canon, you're not making sense.

Yes, I am aware Spiderman isn't black.

They have a series where he is hispanic.

I don't really care what those fans think, race isn't relevant to his character.

it is relevant to the detail of his character.

and no it wont be canon because he's not black.

and in what world was that hispanic parker a canon mainstream?

so okay i'll say that's fine release this movie as an alternate universe spider-man then release a movie with the real spider-man........

i'll jump on board with that....other wise no

did i misread or did someone compare Spiderman to Jesus? Eh, i guess that works, they're both fictional characters.

his race isn't relevant to his character? What world do you live in? Changing his race or any character's race automatically changes the following...

style
culture
dialect/accent/diction
social outlook and social standing amongst peers
demographic they appeal to in the actual word

there are other things to consider as well; point is, it would be a completely different character. Also, they'd have to change the name of not only Spiderman, but his aunt and uncle, his calssmates, and completely revamp the type of women he's attracted to. If you didn't change those things, it would open up a huge can of worms concerning interracial dating and race dynamics in whole due to how much the character gets bullied.

And really, Peter Parker... does that sound like a black teen to you?

^not to mention how jj rides his @$$

Originally posted by Mindset
race isn't relevant to his character.

👆

Originally posted by marwash22
his race isn't relevant to his character? What world do you live in? Changing his race or any character's race automatically changes the following...

style
culture
dialect/accent/diction
social outlook and social standing amongst peers
demographic they appeal to in the actual word

None of those things need be change if the director/writers don't want them to be. Your applying real world social dynamics to a comic book film adaption. I want to you to understand how farfetched you sound.

Again, I'll say wtf are you talking about?!

Here are some real world dynamics that are seen in the previous films, that are, according to you, irrelevant and far-fetched...

Alternative energy
sex/dating
death
finances/poverty
peer pressure and bullying
crime in general
domestic violence and other domesticated issues
politics

So no, it's not me who's applying real world social dynamics to a fictional environment, it's everyone who has ever been involved in the comic book industry since it's inception. Comics books in whole are based on real world circumstances so your entire assertion that these factors are irrelevant, is completely flawed and asinine.

Originally posted by marwash22
And really, Peter Parker... does that sound like a black teen to you?

/thread

Seriously, "Peter Parker" just SOUNDS like a nerdy white guy... Keep him that way.

"Luke Cage" sounds like a big, strong, black guy... Keep him that way.

"Steve Rogers", like "Harvey Dent" or "Wilson Fisk", could be either, tbh... Just as long as the guy can act the part. (and I'm a big Captain America fan)

Originally posted by Bat Dude
/thread

Seriously, "Peter Parker" just SOUNDS like a nerdy white guy... Keep him that way.

"Luke Cage" sounds like a big, strong, black guy... Keep him that way.

"Steve Rogers", like "Harvey Dent" or "Wilson Fisk", could be either, tbh... Just as long as the guy can act the part. (and I'm a big Captain America fan)

If you make Spider-man black you're going to have to change so much about the story it's ridiculous, I mean Marwash hit the nail on the head. I don't want to see a completely altered Spider-man because everyone got this weird mentality of "We have the first black president, so why shouldn't we have the first black Captain America, and Spider-man and everything else"

Originally posted by Menetnashté
If you make Spider-man black you're going to have to change so much about the story it's ridiculous, I mean Marwash hit the nail on the head. I don't want to see a completely altered Spider-man because everyone got this weird mentality of "We have the first black president, so why shouldn't we have the first black Captain America, and Spider-man and everything else"

good words

Originally posted by marwash22
his race isn't relevant to his character? What world do you live in? Changing his race or any character's race automatically changes the following...

style
culture
dialect/accent/diction
social outlook and social standing amongst peers
demographic they appeal to in the actual word

there are other things to consider as well; point is, it would be a completely different character. Also, they'd have to change the name of not only Spiderman, but his aunt and uncle, his calssmates, and completely revamp the type of women he's attracted to. If you didn't change those things, it would open up a huge can of worms concerning interracial dating and race dynamics in whole due to how much the character gets bullied.

And really, Peter Parker... does that sound like a black teen to you?

The style and dialect/accent of a nerdy white person doesn't have to be different from a nerdy black person, stop watching BET.

Spiderman's culture is virtually non existent in the comics.

Social standing among peers? This isn't the 60s. Social outlook doesn't have to be different either, you need to meet more people.

They don't have to change the names or who he is attracted to, wtf? He was bullied because he was a nerd.

Originally posted by BlackZero30x
it is relevant to the detail of his character.

and no it wont be canon because he's not black.

and in what world was that hispanic parker a canon mainstream?

so okay i'll say that's fine release this movie as an alternate universe spider-man then release a movie with the real spider-man........

i'll jump on board with that....other wise no

I don't think you understand canonization. How would a movie reboot where he is black not be canon, how does him being black make it not canon?

All movie Spiderman are alternate universes.

You don't need to jump on board.

You clearly didn't comprehend a damn thing i wrote. Also, I'm black myself and wouldn't be caught dead watching BET; you quick to presume, idiot.

Originally posted by marwash22
You clearly didn't comprehend a damn thing i wrote. Also, I'm black myself and wouldn't be caught dead watching BET; you quick to presume, idiot.

I see you don't have any rebuttal, though.

Originally posted by Mindset
If they make a movie with him being black, it is canon, you're not making sense.

Yes, I am aware Spiderman isn't black.

They have a series where he is hispanic.

I don't really care what those fans think, race isn't relevant to his character.

Originally posted by Mindset
Then I feel sorry that your view on your own race is so limited.

I see you don't have any rebuttal, though.

Originally posted by chomperx9
maybe he is man enough to admit certain things about his race that dont fit right with characters.

Except that he's wrong...

Originally posted by chomperx9
but race is relevant to john stewart, bishop , storm right ? 😉

Bishop, no.

Storm is an african queen and goddess, so...

Originally posted by Bat Dude
/thread

Seriously, "Peter Parker" just SOUNDS like a nerdy white guy... Keep him that way.

"Luke Cage" sounds like a big, strong, black guy... Keep him that way.

"Steve Rogers", like "Harvey Dent" or "Wilson Fisk", could be either, tbh... Just as long as the guy can act the part. (and I'm a big Captain America fan)

Yes because John Stewart sounds Black.