Cross Genre Threads

Started by Trackz18 pages

Originally posted by Black bolt z
lol iron man would demolish DV.
jedi's have some crazy feats outside of their movies.

Originally posted by Trackz
jedi's have some crazy feats outside of their movies.
I know.Still IM would easily beat DV.One repulsor ray and he's down.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
I know.Still IM would easily beat DV.One repulsor ray and he's down.
if the thread gets put up, then we can discuss that

Originally posted by Black bolt z
lol iron man would demolish DV.
Demolish? Nah. Beat? Maybe.

Just remember that Vader also has the ability to end Tony with a casual twitch of his finger... His TK was off the charts.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
I know.Still IM would easily beat DV.One repulsor ray and he's down.
Vader could generate very powerful shielding ala the force. He also possessed formidable pre-cog (ie. he could potentially know what Tony was going to do before he did it, and defend/attack accordingly.)

Don't sell the force short. 😉

I'm not trying to.and I know vader has blocked blaster bolts before but will a constant repulsor say with him flying in a 360 around vader will vader be able to block it?

Originally posted by Black bolt z
I'm not trying to.and I know vader has blocked blaster bolts before but will a constant repulsor say with him flying in a 360 around vader will vader be able to block it?
In the comics, Vader was not limited to blocking blaster bolts with his hands -- he could also generate force-force fields around his entire person.

General Grievous Vs. Batman & Nightwing would be an interesting thread.

Originally posted by Galan007
Yeah, most SW characters have appeared in more comic books then half of the characters allowed in the comic forums... That's why I never understood why SW characters were forbidden here.

srug


have you tried talking to the mods about it?

Ironfist vs Luffy is another interesting one, luffy has crazy damage soak though

Originally posted by illadelph12
General Grievous Vs. Batman & Nightwing would be an interesting thread.
Grievous' ability to deliver 20 saber-strikes per second in conjunction with his insane agility and ground speed, might pose a problem for the duo..

Originally posted by jalek moye
have you tried talking to the mods about it?
Nah.

Originally posted by Galan007

Nah.

you should you have a very good point

Originally posted by Galan007
Yeah, most SW characters have appeared in more comic books then half of the characters allowed in the comic forums... That's why I never understood why SW characters were forbidden here.

srug

It's been explained many times but I'll reiterate with an excerpt from the rules.
Originally posted by Digi
[center]Rules for the matches themselves:

[b]Keep them comic related.

- If there is another forum for discussing the characters, they are banned. This includes game characters, anime/manga, and Star Wars.

- Beyond that, if a character has a regular comic series and is not overwhelmingly viewed in a different medium, they will be allowed. The "primarily viewed in a comic medium" rule is not always in affect, but will be a guideline for moderator discretion.
[/B]

Star Wars is most known for movies in my opinion and the rest of the mods. Opening up Star Wars comics invites every other character which appeared in comics. Since just about every popular movie, anime and Star Wars character has appeared in a comic, the rules were set up as shown above. Letting every character who ever appeared in a comic would be a de facto anything vs forum which Raz and the rest of the mods are against.

The rules will stay as they are. The cross genre thread is just an idea. There will be only one thread at a time after this week. That way it can be monitored easily. The reason why things like this rarely happen is we start getting gripes and complaints for more and more. If that happens here I'll close the threads and not reconsider the idea again. 😬

Originally posted by Galan007
Grievous' ability to deliver 20 saber-strikes per second in conjunction with his insane agility and ground speed, might pose a problem for the duo..

Granted, but the fact his remaining organic components are exposed inside of his exoskeleton and that Batman and Nightwing can use projectiles, explosives (plastiques), and other chemical agents (maybe liquid nitrogen pellets) give them avenues of attack. Going melee would get them dismembered pretty quickly.

I think arguments could be made either way.

iroh (at end of series) vs slade

Originally posted by Badabing
It's been explained many times but I'll reiterate with an excerpt from the rules. Star Wars is most known for movies in my opinion and the rest of the mods. Opening up Star Wars comics invites every other character which appeared in comics. Since just about every popular movie, anime and Star Wars character has appeared in a comic, the rules were set up as shown above. Letting every character who ever appeared in a comic would be a de facto anything vs forum which Raz and the rest of the mods are against.

The rules will stay as they are. The cross genre thread is just an idea. There will be only one thread at a time after this week. That way it can be monitored easily. The reason why things like this rarely happen is we start getting gripes and complaints for more and more. If that happens here I'll close the threads and not reconsider the idea again. 😬

Also, Star Wars is a bit of a sacred cow around here to the powers that be, so it gets very touchy very quickly when one of it's characters ends up on the losing end of a debate. Being a person without a genre/franchise bias I didn't appreciate how sensitive some people can be about it.

static vs. aang or naruto might be interesting.

Originally posted by Badabing
It's been explained many times but I'll reiterate with an excerpt from the rules. Star Wars is most known for movies in my opinion and the rest of the mods. Opening up Star Wars comics invites every other character which appeared in comics. Since just about every popular movie, anime and Star Wars character has appeared in a comic, the rules were set up as shown above. Letting every character who ever appeared in a comic would be a de facto anything vs forum which Raz and the rest of the mods are against.

The rules will stay as they are. The cross genre thread is just an idea. There will be only one thread at a time after this week. That way it can be monitored easily. The reason why things like this rarely happen is we start getting gripes and complaints for more and more. If that happens here I'll close the threads and not reconsider the idea again. 😬

Yeah I figured that would be the 'go to' argument against SW threads in the comic forums, and I don't necessarily disagree with it. I do, however, still think it's odd that SW has (literally) thousands of comics to it's name AND it's published by Dark Horse, yet it's still a no-no here. Meh, whatevs.

Anyhow, I would highly suggest not allowing DBZ-related threads (especially in this trial period.) With some of the arguments currently going on in them I can see the whole 'cross-genre allowance' thing being swiftly shut down (again), and that would be a horrible waste, because imo this forum needs a change like that. /shrug

Originally posted by illadelph12
Granted, but the fact his remaining organic components are exposed inside of his exoskeleton and that Batman and Nightwing can use projectiles, explosives (plastiques), and other chemical agents (maybe liquid nitrogen pellets) give them avenues of attack. Going melee would get them dismembered pretty quickly.

I think arguments could be made either way.

Getting to those organic components would likely be a b*tch for them, but yeah...

Originally posted by Trackz
static vs. aang or naruto might be interesting.
as long as avatar state isnt included mmm

Originally posted by Galan007
Grievous' ability to deliver 20 saber-strikes per second in conjunction with his insane agility and ground speed, might pose a problem for the duo..

Nah.

Did somebody actually say Batman could compete with Grievous? LOL LOL. That is amusing. Batman would get wtf pwnd by all high level jedi and sith practioners

grievous is not a force-user; but yea, i agree