Hmm.. I think if this was with no gear at all then both DD and Cap are slightly > Bats/BP. Armor should even the odds, particularly BP`s, tho it might not be as much an advantage as it seems. It slows them down however slightly and kevlar not protect the brain from bouncing inside your skull causing a KO.
Pretty even, still a slight advantage to team 1 IMO.
If this is superhuman BP then T2 wins.