Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Rip apart something as durable as granite? I dont think so. YuLaw is gonna tag Edward over and over, but I dont see any real damage being dealt.
\
You're forgetting that a vampire can punch through another vampire because they are strong enough.
If Yu-Law is as strong as a vampire, or stronger (as I believe), then he should be able to punch right through Edward.
Originally posted by marwash22
Speed - Ed
Strength - Ed
Durability - EdYulaw's greatest strength feat is lifting the two bikes at once and since they were equals, you can use Law's greatest strength feat which was kicking that gas station pole. Both are impressive, but Ed could do both considering he knocked over a tree with one hand. Yulaw is by far the better fighter so he'd kick Ed's ass somethin' terrible, but wouldn't do any damage 'cause he's not strong enough to crack granite.
You also have to factor in all the different way Ed could kill Yulaw, none of which can be done to Ed.
Cullen wins due to durability.
No, Yu-Law has the greater strength feat. While Edward treated that moving van like Styrofoam, it takes a lot more strength to pick up those bikes and swing them, from their extreme ends. He held the bikes out in front of himself.
Sure, both treat vehicle like styrofoam, but Yu-Law has the greater strength feat.
Bella did say the Emmett could throw a vehicle like it was paper in the book (that's a paraphrase), but that was only to Emmett and Emmett is the strongest of the Cullen coven.
Speed is definitely Yu-Law...as far as combat speed goes.
Durability is definitely Edward.
Edit - There's a minor problem with my logic: Edward can read thoughts and he was so good at it that the Cullen's best fighter (second fastest and second strongest, Jasper) couldn't land one hit on Edward. Edward is very fast, but he's significantly behind Yu -Law. Edward would have to be able to read Yu-Law's thoughts AND react fast enough to Yu-Law's superior combat speed. In a straight line, sure, Edward is far faster, but combat speed, they are not even close. For me, the difference in speed is not as much as it is between a twivamp and a Force User, but it's still too much of a difference to overcome.