Wade/Mello or Bron

List in order

1-3

Overall
1.LeBron
2.Wade
3.Melo

Wade can match LeBron on a certain night but not for a whole season.

Offense
1.LeBron
2.Wade
3.Melo

Overall, I'd have to say that LeBron and Wade are far above Melo in most offensive skills not called scoring.

Scoring (specifically)
1.Melo
2.LeBron
3.Wade

Melo is ahead of these two by alot in this area.

Defense
1.LeBron
2.Wade
3.Melo

Wade can be the best when he puts himself to it(ahem, Kobe) but LeBron is more consistent. Melo isn't a slouch in this area either......when he tries.

Although it is worth noting that if it weren't for the Pistons forcing an injury upon Wade in the 04-05 ECF the Heat might have won the championship. Shaq was beastly that year and Wade was just starting to truly shine in the playoffs.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
[B]Overall

Overall, I'd have to say that LeBron and Wade are far above Melo in most offensive skills not called scoring.

[/B]

Originally posted by Mindset
What do you mean by this, like asts and off rbs?

Meaning they could play point guard because there passing skills are so good whereas Anthony isn't polished in that area.

Yup.. You are right I am agree with you..!!!

Originally posted by Mindset
What do you mean by this, like asts and off rbs?

Wade
Bron
Melo

bron
melo
wade

melo is above wade because hes better defensively, has a better shot, and is a better scoring player

Better shot? Check.
Better scorer? Check.
Better defensively? Nope.

Better playmaker? Nope.

Test I - Pick the item that does not belong in the group:

1. Wade, Melo, LeBron

Answer: Melo