Thor vs Doomsday

Started by TheLordofMurder5 pages

Depends on how Thor kills him...

If Thor kills him by taking his soul, I somehow doubt that any version of Doomsday can evolve against that...

I don't think DD has a soul.

Why is Doomsy evolving an issue? It is DOS Doomsday vs Thor, who can put the other down for a win. Not a series of rounds where DD evolves each time.

That's how it will be in the comics, though. Which is why superman has had problems.

Originally posted by Prep-Man
I don't think DD has a soul.

Its possible that he doesnt and in the event that he is written as not possessing one, I wouldnt be surprised...

That said, he is (in the simplest sense) an extremely evolved biological life form and virtually all of these have souls...so it stands to reason that DD has one too (unless a given writter doesnt want DD to lose to Thor like this).

As a result I see no logical reason why DD cant fall prey to this type of assault from Thor...nor can I think of a logical way he could evolve against this (or even rise from the dead as his soul will be banished to whatever hell Thor sends it to at the conclusion of this attack)...

fight 1 - hammer smash for the win
fight 2 - uber magical lightning for the win
fight 3 - godblast for the win
fight 4 - soul suck for the win
fight 5 - bfr for the win
fight 6 onwards till infinity ds doomsday wins.

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Its possible that he doesnt and in the event that he is written as not possessing one, I wouldnt be surprised...

That said, he is (in the simplest sense) an extremely evolved biological life form and virtually all of these have souls...so it stands to reason that DD has one too (unless a given writter doesnt want DD to lose to Thor like this).

As a result I see no logical reason why DD cant fall prey to this type of assault from Thor...nor can I think of a logical way he could evolve against this (or even rise from the dead as his soul will be banished to whatever hell Thor sends it to at the conclusion of this attack)...

No, I think it was actually stated that he had no soul. He was designed to be the perfect life form and is somewhat immortal.

Being immortal doesnt equate to not having a soul; the Olympian Gods are immortal and possess souls afterall...

Do you have a scan of it being stated that DD is soulless?

Originally posted by Stoic
I gave it a thought, and believe that you're completely correct. If Doomsday could in any incarnation beat all of the heroes that he did, and swat Superman aside like an annoying tick, Thor battling Doomsday would be nearly comparable with him fighting the Destroyer construct, and he would lose nearly as bad.

Doomsday 8/10

qft 👆
this shoudl persuade everyone!

DD for majority

It doesnt persuade me...

Explain to me how DD deals with Thor's spiritual attack then I might agree with you...

Originally posted by Mshinu
DOS Doomsy goes down hard, no doubt about it.
Originally posted by gogogadgetgo
fight 1 - hammer smash for the win
fight 2 - uber magical lightning for the win
fight 3 - godblast for the win
fight 4 - soul suck for the win
fight 5 - bfr for the win
fight 6 onwards till infinity ds doomsday wins.

THOR WOULD BE CREATING UNSTOPPABLE BEAST

anyway thor beat dos easily, supes wasnt all that back around DOS times. And he was still DOS DDs superior, but after DOS doomsday became a beast. REX is the only doomsday that is a debate for Thor. I personally believe thor would lose to rex. But its a slight win, and if anyone said thor wins its a respectable choice aswell. But that can not be said for HP doomsday, he beats thor easily.

Thor would beat the shit out of DoS Doomsday. And anyone arguing that Doomsday will be adapting on the fly to defeat Thor doesn't know what their talking about.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Thor would beat the shit out of DoS Doomsday. And anyone arguing that Doomsday will be adapting on the fly to defeat Thor doesn't know what their talking about.
DoS dd killed superman and defeated the justice league. he ain't no cakewalk.

Originally posted by Starscream M
DoS dd killed superman and defeated the justice league. he ain't no cakewalk.
nope but well writen thor would pumel that particular JLA also.... 😎

Originally posted by Starscream M
DoS dd killed superman and defeated the justice league. he ain't no cakewalk.

Stalemating Superman to the death is a great feat, but that Superman was inferior to current era levels. He was no slouch but he gets hammered down like he was in JLA/Avengers panel (I'm not actually using that as evidence.). Unless you wish to count for inflating power levels.

I just realized that Thor is probably one of the few Elite Top Tiers that hasn't received a permanent upgrade.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Stalemating Superman to the death is a great feat, but that Superman was inferior to current era levels. He was no slouch but he gets hammered down like he was in JLA/Avengers panel (I'm not actually using that as evidence.). Unless you wish to count for inflating power levels.

I just realized that Thor is probably one of the few Elite Top Tiers that hasn't received a permanent upgrade.

how would thor put DD down? DD was fast enough to dodge Superman

Originally posted by Starscream M
how would thor put DD down? DD was fast enough to dodge Superman

By throwing Mjolnir at his face.

Thor beats DOS Doomsday to death.

Thor