Originally posted by Stoic
Great post, my thing here is that Thor can split mountain ranges with his hammer with ease, yet he was unable to even move Thanos with it. Like I pointed out before, Thanos in those days was far weaker than he is now due to various upgrades given by Lady Death
Thanks!
I feel what you're saying, but the big cheese feats don't necessarily mean much in relation to the effectiveness of 1v1 attacks in comics. Like, is one really to believe that Surfer can survive the crushing pressures of a black hole, but a hammer blow knocks him out? Same deal for any characters like that -- if Black Holes aren't knocking out Superman and Green Lantern (and GL's are creating constructs to seal them, no less!), what should realistically be able to hurt them through their shields? Nothing.
Thor HAS hurt Thanos while he had the Infinity Gauntlet, and actually seemed to be getting the better of that direct physical confrontation, until Thanos used the gauntlet to turn him into blocks, lol. And again in Blood and Thunder Thor (powered up, but to what degree we don't know -- he was only tapping into the gem unconsciously, remember, and when Drax was doing this it only made him ON PAR with Professor Hulk in strength) he was able to draw blood and basically it seemed as though Thanos wouldn't have been able to take him out straight up, or at least not very quickly.
He's also been knocked out/stunned by some random energy blaster. Hurting him is definitely difficult, but it's not impossible.
Also, I should mention that I'm talking about 'classic' Thanos, not the current version. I haven't seen enough of him to really be able to gauge what level he's on, overall. So basically I'm talking about the Thanos before he died in Annihilation. So far as I know, his power was increased by Death upon his resurrection, but that is the only real power up he got. (I've heard people say that he got one after The End, but that's a large logical leap to make given what was presented, that he had granted himself a few 'life assuring wishes' such as the return of his fleet of ships).
Back to Thor hitting Thanos with his hammer; are we to believe that Thor was pulling his punches against a guy that he witnessed one shot the Thing, or should we go with Thor realizing that Thanos was badass enough to cut loose on after witnessing such and such? I'm going with option 2.
I'm not going to try to rationalize what went on there, but ultimately (as I recall it) Thanos took like one real hammer shot and then started wailing on Thor with his eye beams (and as Rage has said, Thor took a number of those). In terms of real hand to hand, we didn't see a hell of a lot of that.
My point is do you believe that Orion can hit harder than Thor does with Mjolnir using only his bare hands as this thread suggests?
I think that, in comics, the difference is fairly negligible re; power of Thor's hammer vs power of Thor's fists. Superman caught it in JLA/Avengers, and took a number of blows from the hammer, without falling, for instance. I don't think it gives him a sizeable advantage in striking power over just his strength.
But more than that, it's the precision that I think would make the difference. Depending on which Orion we've got fighting here, martial arts is more than just brawling, it's about precise hits to inflict maximum damage. And while I don't think any ONE of Orion's blows is going to lay Thanos out, I think he's more than strong enough to wear him down with a number of hits, and I think he's more than fast/skilled enough to have the time to do so.
Thanos wasn't fazed by Thors blow, should we believe that Orion with only his fists can hurt or daze a guy that can take the pressures of a black hole, and come out with a few scratches and cuts?
It's interesting that you say this, because in point of fact we have SEEN Thor's hammer lay out a guy (the Silver Surfer) who has taken black holes FAR better than Thanos did. Thanos looked to be on his last legs, bleeding and pock marked, where as Surfer has fought in the center of one with no problem, and has even CREATED them.
Do you believe that Thanos lacks the power to hurt Orion after witnessing the beating that he gave the Silver Surfer with his bare hands?
No, absolutely not. Thanos is stronger than Orion, and more durable besides. But the dynamics of an Orion/Thanos fight are going to be very different than the dynamics of a Thanos/Silver Surfer fight. If Orion was as ineffective in hand to hand as the Surfer was, he'd absolutely lose to.
But, of course, Orion ISN'T.
but let's also keep in mind that Orion doesn't possess a spider sense, and isn't a precog but, wait the Surfer can dodge meteor storms while travelling at ftl speeds because of his cosmic awareness. See what I'm getting at?
And yet we've seen the Silver Surfer get pounded on, in terms of combat speed, by Spiderman or Midnight Sun (an old school Shang Chi foe). Clearly his combat speed is essentially normal in such situations. To the best of my knowledge, Thanos has ALWAYS performed poorly against characters with enhanced reflexes/combat super speed (the Runner, Gamora, Spiderman)...relative to how he SHOULD do, anyway.
Orion would be coming into this battle lacking the power to finish his opponent. Thanos would not.
Agree to disagree, even as I admit/agree that THanos would take the majority.