What comic character would make the best Jedi?

Started by Lord_Talron7 pages

he also uses rather questionable methods. and fear.

Originally posted by Lord_Talron
he also uses rather questionable methods. and fear.
Not sure the jedi code is against using fear.Just giving into it.

And batman wouldn't turn to the dark side.If 50 years of the joker doesn't...

Amadeus Cho

Batman, of course.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Not sure the jedi code is against using fear.Just giving into it.

And batman wouldn't turn to the dark side.If 50 years of the joker doesn't...

yes, but you arent supposed to succumb to evil and since batman is basically chaotic good with morals against killing, he does a lot of "the end justifies the means" stuff

John Stewart, maybe... but definitely not Hal. 😖hifty:

Originally posted by Lord_Talron
yes, but you arent supposed to succumb to evil and since batman is basically chaotic good with morals against killing, he does a lot of "the end justifies the means" stuff
Exactly.He would make a good jedi.Other then say torturing...

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Exactly.He would make a good jedi.Other then say torturing...

When has Batman actually tortured someone? And I don't mean putting a scare or dangling over a ledge, I mean electric shocks to the testicles or hot irons to the nape of the neck type torture.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
When has Batman actually tortured someone? And I don't mean putting a scare or dangling over a ledge, I mean electric shocks to the testicles or hot irons to the nape of the neck type torture.
I didn't mean that either.I meant like threating to kill.

In the clone wars series ahsoka threatened to kill nute gunray and anikan(at least I think it was anikan)told her not to because its not the jedi way.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
I didn't mean that either.I meant like threating to kill.

In the clone wars series ahsoka threatened to kill nute gunray and anikan(at least I think it was anikan)told her not to because its not the jedi way.

lol. typical anakin. hypocrisy ftw.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
I didn't mean that either.I meant like threating to kill.

In the clone wars series ahsoka threatened to kill nute gunray and anikan(at least I think it was anikan)told her not to because its not the jedi way.


And then in a later episode he kills a guy (from behind no less) without batting an eye. He was justified IMO but the way he pretty much just brushes it off casually is an eerie premonition to his Darth Vader future.
Originally posted by -Pr-
lol. typical anakin. hypocrisy ftw.

IIRC it wasn't Anakin, it was Luminara.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
And then in a later episode he kills a guy (from behind no less) without batting an eye. He was justified IMO but the way he pretty much just brushes it off casually is an eerie premonition to his Darth Vader future.

IIRC it wasn't Anakin, it was Luminara.

Who did he kill and in what context?

And that doesn't change the fact that its not the jedi way.So besides stuff like that batman would make a good jedi.

Jedi threatened to kill in the movies. I really don't see it being a big deal.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Who did he kill and in what context?

And that doesn't change the fact that its not the jedi way.So besides stuff like that batman would make a good jedi.


A Mandalorian traitor who was holding Dutchess Satine at gunpoint and threatening to blow up the ship they were on. Really killing him was the only logical action but Anakin should have showed some remorse about it rather than (almost cheerily) saying "What? He was going to blow up the ship"

Originally posted by -Pr-
Jedi threatened to kill in the movies. I really don't see it being a big deal.
Who did they threaten to kill?The only reason mace was going to kill palpatine was because he was a goddamn sith lord.And he had controll of the senates and the courts.

I guess it works with what OV is saying.As in the words of mace windu hes "too dangerous to be kept alive".

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Who did they threaten to kill?The only reason mace was going to kill palpatine was because he was a goddamn sith lord.And he had controll of the senates and the courts.

I guess it works with what OV is saying.As in the words of mace windu hes "too dangerous to be kept alive".

mace also threatened jango with his saber in front of dooku. in the first movie they intimidated jar jar in to helping them.

in the series anakin is an evil little shit at times, and yet nobody calls him out on it.

Originally posted by -Pr-
mace also threatened jango with his saber in front of dooku. in the first movie they intimidated jar jar in to helping them.

in the series anakin is an evil little shit at times, and yet nobody calls him out on it.

He didn't even threaten him.He just ignited his saber behind him.And if your too dangerous a jedi is willing to kill.

I don't remember them intimidating jar jar.

I met the guy that does the voice of anikan.Didn't seem to evil 😕

Mantis or Moondragon would be teaching Obi Wan in the ways of the Force inside a year...

Originally posted by Black bolt z
He didn't even threaten him.He just ignited his saber behind him.And if your too dangerous a jedi is willing to kill.

I don't remember them intimidating jar jar.

I met the guy that does the voice of anikan.Didn't seem to evil 😕

his saber was by jango's throat.

the character =/= actor 😛

Originally posted by darthgoober
Mantis or Moondragon would be teaching Obi Wan in the ways of the Force inside a year...

This^

Plus I'd say Iron Fist, Karnak, and Karate Kid would also make great Jedi.

Mental discipline is the key.