Originally posted by Galan007
So yeah, full-potential power/ability is what we go by. Having a 'CIS-free' battle really doesn't change things much, imo.
That we uses the character as the whole not simply his powers.
yes it does, it no longer that character using his abilities it us. That changes the match completely.
I literally couldn't understand anything you said in the first part of your post.
As for the second part: Yeah we do use the characters as a whole. But that doesn't change the fact that they still fight to the best of their ability. For instance, even though Flash really doesn't blitz enough for it to be considered 'in character' for him, his ability to do so in a forum match was specifically listed as an example in the rules.
Stop arguing just to argue.
Originally posted by Galan007
I literally couldn't understand anything you said in the first part of your post.As for the second part: Yeah we do use the characters as a whole. But that doesn't change the fact that they still fight to the best of their ability. For instance, even though Flash really doesn't blitz enough for it to be considered 'in character' for him, his ability to do so in a forum match was specifically listed as an example in the rules.
Stop arguing just to argue.
I never said they dident fight to there best ability, but it with in there personality. Flash has speed blizt numerous times. Well within the right to uses such a tactic as an option.
I am not, thats what your doing. I making a valid point based off the rules of the board. They fight the best they can within there personality. The personality makes a huge deference. For example with CIS off people would simply have colossus Thunder clap the shit out of most anyone he was set up against, with cis on he won't even attempt it.
Originally posted by Galan007
Good, then we agree.I didn't reply to the rest of your post because it'd just be me restating what I've already stated.
or the fact you know my arguement made 100% logical senses and you don't have an arguement for it........
Originally posted by Dum Dum DuganSee, this is what I mean by you arguing just to argue. I tried to stop our discussion because I loathe circular arguments, yet you persisted.
so your entire arguement was pointless? and you said I was argueing to argue?or the fact you know my arguement made 100% logical senses and you don't have an arguement for it........
Anywho, I understood what you were saying the entire time. I just got the impression that you thought CIS prohibited a character from operating to their full capacity. It doesn't. That was my only point.
So please stop trying to pick arguments. There's really no need. 🙂
Originally posted by Galan007
See, this is what I mean by you arguing just to argue. I tried to stop our discussion because I loathe circular arguments, yet you persisted.Anywho, I understood what you were saying the entire time. I just got the impression that you thought CIS prohibited a character from operating to their full capacity. It doesn't. That was my only point.
So please stop trying to pick arguments. There's really no need. 🙂
Originally posted by The NuulIf that's how the mods want it, then okay. But if that is in fact the case, they definitely need to edit the full capacity rule I posted earlier.
Too bad muffin, you are wrong and so is Shoko about Superman threads.In the rules thread about CIS and said by Paul.
"It ALL comes down to the CHARACTER, not the POWERSET."
Originally posted by Galan007
If that's how the mods want it, then okay. But if that is in fact the case, they definitely need to edit the full capacity rule I posted earlier.
Thats the hard part IMO. FC but with in character.
Shokos way is Supes blitzs right off of the start = the wrong way.
The right way is Supes takes a few hits from Hulk then realizes that hey WTF! then brings the pain and stomps.
We dont want a CBR, HC or those other shit forums. This rule is good.
As for this thread....
CIS off means that Logan will go for the kill and at his best.
Originally posted by The NuulWhich is contradictive for many characters. And like I said earlier, the current rule implies that abilities supersede demeanor. I don't really care either way, though... Just nitpicking certain inconsistencies. 😉
FC but with in character.
Originally posted by King CastleHope you aren't referring to me. 😕
its bn the rule for years i cant believe some one who has bn here for years has just figured it out an d thought otherwise..facepalm2
combo to ko logic.superdur
Originally posted by Galan007A lot of rules need a make over
If that's how the mods want it, then okay. But if that is in fact the case, they definitely need to edit the full capacity rule I posted earlier.
for example:
officially there is no 6/10 or 8/10, this whole X out of 10 doesn't exist it's just 1 fight.
or prep time is far away how it is used in debates here.
and how can you really BFR someone in a big white room?
EDIT: ^ This works in lots of cases though just not all.
I don't think it did though. I mean superman blizting right off the bat is kinda a stretch. Nor does the original rules go against that either. Just becuase superman at his best does not mean he gunna auto blizt everyone, the fact he in character would prevent such a tactic from the get go, but he would certainly uses it if needed. I think this has always been the case's however certain people have been unable to grasp it I feel and this is why the rules had to be up dated and made more clearly defined. People were manipulating the broadness of the original explanation to there advantage.
Originally posted by Parmaniac
A lot of rules need a make overfor example:
officially there is no 6/10 or 8/10, this whole X out of 10 doesn't exist it's just 1 fight.
that makes sense though, we just that to say how likely someone is to win and stuff. Only reason it had to be specified because people started saying characters will win 9/10 because they lose the first fight then become immune and stuff.
Or a chaarcter who gets stronger from fighting having an amp i n5 of the fights etc.
superman would only combo to ko if he had detail knowledge and past experience of what it would take to put an opponent down...
supes would never try a combo to ko on guys like cap, spiderman, absorbing man etc ect at least not till he knew how strong they were 1st hand otherwise he risk murdering which would be out of character.