Originally posted by Mshinu
Hulk is barely worth half a pimp slap. When Thanos wants to test himself he seeks out far far greater foes.
DP Tyrant dishes out more punishment in a single fight than Hulkie Boy could in a month.
You forgot to include the artifact that thanos hade with him that amped his abilities while fighting tyrant. He didn't do that under his own power.
Originally posted by Nihilist
He took 3 consecutive hits from Thor amped by the Power gem, 1 from Magus who had 5 infinity gems, shitloads from a more powerfull than him Thanos doppleganger and blasts from Odin,Tyrant and Walker that are stronger than any punch Hulk can throw.
And thor has taken hits from celestials, odin in the destroyer armor, galactus, an angry odin, mangog, and the list goes on but guess what? Thor would still fall to hulks fist if it came down to it.
Originally posted by carver9
You forgot to include the artifact that thanos hade with him that amped his abilities while fighting tyrant. He didn't do that under his own power.
I don`t recall it amping Thanos in any way except he hit Tyrant in the head with the orb once or twice. Thanos stated he wanted to see who was the mightier so I doubt he`d cheat.. much.
Originally posted by Nihilist
He took 3 consecutive hits from Thor amped by the Power gem, 1 from Magus who had 5 infinity gems, shitloads from a more powerfull than him Thanos doppleganger and blasts from Odin,Tyrant and Walker that are stronger than any punch Hulk can throw.
Thor in that state was hardly capable of accessing the Power Gems true output, so you can't even begin to quantify the feat. As far as we know he was fighting a highly enraged Thor, something which Professor Hulk did in the Antarctic, and he was doing just fine.
Magus did not fully connect with Thanos, or he would have split him open like a ripe melon, try again. The Hulk took out Onslaughts physical form, which was something that no one could do including Thor, who looked pretty helpless. Thanos is very durable, I'll give you that, but so is a dimensional barrier, and a weaker Hulk broke through one, with his fists... Try not to make it seem like Thanos would laugh one of those punches off, because you and I both know that after taking one, he'd be dodging the next.
Thanos used an orb to barely stop Tyrant, doesn't count.
Thanos' doppelganger was obviously weaker than the real thing or the entire confrontation was PIS... Do you think that you would be able to defeat yourself if the other you had all of your attributes but they were augmented? Or maybe the clone won... hmmm. Didn't the clone believe himself to be the real Thanos?
Originally posted by thanos-prime
Try and know what your talking about before you post, the galactus that got launched was specifically stated to be well fed and hadn't fought the hunger yet and btw that is in no way a strength feat and not his best even if it were skrulls also have unique physiology and he transmuted one of them into stone.lol he only towers over him in your dreams guy,when was it stated he was immune to mental attacks?has taken hits from Tyrant(DP),PG thor,lord mar-vell(possibly trans tier) etc etc.
How well did that work when Professor X, and Emma tried to calm the Hulk down? How well did Sentry's calming light work? How well do you think Thanos' mind whammy would work... Oh wait, let me answer for you, it won't work. The Hulk has demonstrated several times that he has very strong resistances to mind assaults when enraged. Like I said the Power Gem in Thor's possession should never be counted as a feat. Thanos for all we know was fighting an enraged Thor who was incapable of tapping into the Gem... Here's a tip, leave that fight out of any proof that you think that you have, that Thanos would beat the Hulk... When it happens we will all see how bad Thanos is. Thanos was being amped when he fought Tyrant... you know what I mean dude?
You still have yet to prove that Thanos is as strong as the Hulk. On panel Thanos has never shown that he can lift anywhere near what the Hulk has. Marvel says that the Hulk is the strongest, not Thanos guy. Wait but before you start stating things like strength isn't everything, keep in mind that for a big guy the Hulk can fight.
If Thanos was dumb enough to slug it out with the Hulk he would get put out, he may be immortal but he can still be ko'd. I also hope you don't try and make it seem like Thanos is impervious to damage because i just saw him reduced to a skeleton. Did you?
Originally posted by StoicThor was obviously tapping into it subconsciously if they wanted him to fight an enraged thor there would have been no reason to give him the gem in the first place...
Thor in that state was hardly capable of accessing the Power Gems true output, so you can't even begin to quantify the feat. As far as we know he was fighting a highly enraged Thor, something which Professor Hulk did in the Antarctic, and he was doing just fine.Magus did not fully connect with Thanos, or he would have split him open like a ripe melon, try again. The Hulk took out Onslaughts physical form, which was something that no one could do including Thor, who looked pretty helpless. Thanos is very durable, I'll give you that, but so is a dimensional barrier, and a weaker Hulk broke through one, with his fists... Try not to make it seem like Thanos would laugh one of those punches off, because you and I both know that after taking one, he'd be dodging the next.
Thanos used an orb to barely stop Tyrant, doesn't count.
Thanos' doppelganger was obviously weaker than the real thing or the entire confrontation was PIS... Do you think that you would be able to defeat yourself if the other you had all of your attributes but they were augmented? Or maybe the clone won... hmmm. Didn't the clone believe himself to be the real Thanos?
How well did that work when Professor X, and Emma tried to calm the Hulk down? How well did Sentry's calming light work? How well do you think Thanos' mind whammy would work... Oh wait, let me answer for you, it won't work. The Hulk has demonstrated several times that he has very strong resistances to mind assaults when enraged. Like I said the Power Gem in Thor's possession should never be counted as a feat. Thanos for all we know was fighting an enraged Thor who was incapable of tapping into the Gem... Here's a tip, leave that fight out of any proof that you think that you have, that Thanos would beat the Hulk... When it happens we will all see how bad Thanos is. Thanos was being amped when he fought Tyrant... you know what I mean dude?
You still have yet to prove that Thanos is as strong as the Hulk. On panel Thanos has never shown that he can lift anywhere near what the Hulk has. Marvel says that the Hulk is the strongest, not Thanos guy. Wait but before you start stating things like strength isn't everything, keep in mind that for a big guy the Hulk can fight.
If Thanos was dumb enough to slug it out with the Hulk he would get put out, he may be immortal but he can still be ko'd. I also hope you don't try and make it seem like Thanos is impervious to damage because i just saw him reduced to a skeleton. Did you?
Originally posted by thanos-prime
Thor was obviously tapping into it subconsciously if they wanted him to fight an enraged thor there would have been no reason to give him the gem in the first place...
your right thanos was being amp'd but this was also before he recieved two upgrades in power and it was also stated that after the fight he added that orb to his own power so that fight does count.For villans i don't use lifting feats more often than not i use punching power feats and in that category thanos is easily as strong if not stronger.Hulk says hulk is the strongest i have seen interviews where hulk writers have said thanos is stronger and would win in a fight.Thanos just got an even bigger blunt force durability upgrade on top of being immortal and after he came back from being reduced to a skeleton he was even more durable.And on a side note i do agree that more often than not thanos would lose to curent hulk hand to hand good thing that's not what this is.
You know I don't believe all of what you wrote. You know that right? Thor was whipping the Infinity Watches collective asses before getting the Gem, which within itself was impressive, so you can not call it a quantifiable feat for Thanos, nor does it imply that Thor was tapping the Gem in the least. If it can't be proven let's move on.
Writers over canonical history now? Writers had Captain America one shot the Hulk off panel, writers had Thanos get locked up and carted away to jail, writers had She Hulk KO the Champion, writers had Batman KO Superman.... should I continue? My point is that there are many people out there who hate the Hulk, or Thanos, or Superman, or Spiderman the list is huge, but most of the times these writers pay no attention to detail, and end up clowning themselves. The Hulk is stronger than Thanos, and can attain far greater strength than he has. Thanos' thing is durability, but like I said before, The Hulk was able to break through a mystically seal dimensional barrier. Is Thanos more durable than the partition of two dimensions? I highly doubt it.
Until I see them fight it out one on one, saying that Thanos would beat the Hulk or that the Hulk would beat Thanos is highly speculative. Also the Hulk has some pretty mean team mates in this thread, and I can see him losing this fight while being picked apart by the Ray, Kyle, and Magneto in air raids, while taking huge physical impacts from the Hulk. Not to mention that he can go world breaker on Thanos. A casual footfall nearly sank the entire eastern seaboard, and he was holding back.
Listen like I said Thanos is bad, but don't sleep on Banner.
Originally posted by StoicLOl your the one that brought the writers opinion into this then try to lecture me when one of of the hulks biggest writers says thanos can beat him? Don't believe what i wrote but that doesn't make it anyless true because you don't like it, and for that PG argument i believe when thanos encased him in that forceblock it was said that he was growing steadidly stronger and would soon break out a side effect of the PG.Thanos is just as strong if not stronger than hulk and on top of that more powerful if he were just durable he would beat top tiers asses he would just hang.Use all high feats much try using his average not every hit he is going to hit him with is going to be a dimensional rip closer.
You know I don't believe all of what you wrote. You know that right? Thor was whipping the Infinity Watches collective asses before getting the Gem, which within itself was impressive, so you can not call it a quantifiable feat for Thanos, nor does it imply that Thor was tapping the Gem in the least. If it can't be proven let's move on.Writers over canonical history now? Writers had Captain America one shot the Hulk off panel, writers had Thanos get locked up and carted away to jail, writers had She Hulk KO the Champion, writers had Batman KO Superman.... should I continue? My point is that there are many people out there who hate the Hulk, or Thanos, or Superman, or Spiderman the list is huge, but most of the times these writers pay no attention to detail, and end up clowning themselves. The Hulk is stronger than Thanos, and can attain far greater strength than he has. Thanos' thing is durability, but like I said before, The Hulk was able to break through a mystically seal dimesional barrier. Is Thanos more durable than the partition of two dimensions? I highly doubt it.
Until I see them fight it out one on one, saying that Thanos would beat the Hulk or that the Hulk would beat Thanos is highly speculative. Also the Hulk has some pretty mean team mates in this thread, and I can see him losing this fight while being picked apart by the Ray, Kyle, and Magneto in air raids, while taking huge physical impacts from the Hulk. Not to mention that he can go world breaker on Thanos. A casual footfall nearly sank the entire eastern seaboard, and he was holding back.
Listen like I said Thanos is bad, but don't sleep on Banner.
Originally posted by thanos-prime
LOl your the one that brought the writers opinion into this then try to lecture me when one of of the hulks biggest writers says thanos can beat him? Don't believe what i wrote but that doesn't make it anyless true because you don't like it, and for that PG argument i believe when thanos encased him in that forceblock it was said that he was growing steadidly stronger and would soon break out a side effect of the PG.Thanos is just as strong if not stronger than hulk and on top of that more powerful if he were just durable he would beat top tiers asses he would just hang.Use all high feats much try using his average not every hit he is going to hit him with is going to be a dimensional rip closer.
The Hulk was walking through Top Tiers like air when he was weaker and mindless (Hercules, Ironman, Namor, Wonder Man, Samson, and two Avengers teams). Don't pass the buck on me when you were the one that brought the Hulk writer or was it writers into this, not me. Do you have a memory problem? There are pills that you can take for that condition. Or are you replying to the PIS that happened with the clone debacle? It was PIS, but then again, what does that pedantic point have to do with anything?
One Hulk writer may say one thing while another would say something else. When was this stated? 20 years ago? New Hulk = New Perspective.
The problem with the Hulk is that the longer he continues fighting Thanos the higher the feats will become, and eventually (like a minute) he'll be in dimensional ripping strength range. Ask me how long it took him to reach the strength necessary to open that dimensional partiton. You know what I'll tell you, it took him about 30 seconds.
Did you know that a 2 inch Hulk nearly KO'd a true class 100? Yeah the Abomination nearly took flight when he was hit by a 2 inch Hulk, and that was Professor Hulk.
I see that this can go on and on, but my stance won't change. The Hulk is a threat alone, and he has some pretty potent energy users on his team. Gotta go study.
Originally posted by StoicMe have memory problems seems your the one who is forgetting saying marvel says hulk is the strongest there is so in essence saying the writers say he is.I believe what hulk writer said it about worldwarhulk.like i said in my previous post try not basing your argument on all high feats.You say true class 100 as if thanos isn't and which abomination was it?your right hulk is a threat alone if it were to stay hand to hand but the fact is it doesn't have to thanos has many ways of dealing with hulk instantly or eventually but he can deal with him and imo he would go for bfr considering how many other people are in this fight.
The Hulk was walking through Top Tiers like air when he was weaker and mindless (Hercules, Ironman, Namor, Wonder Man, Samson, and two Avengers teams). Don't pass the buck on me when you were the one that brought the Hulk writer or was it writers into this, not me. Do you have a memory problem? There are pills that you can take for that condition. Or are you replying to the PIS that happened with the clone debacle? It was PIS, but then again, what does that pedantic point have to do with anything?One Hulk writer may say one thing while another would say something else. When was this stated? 20 years ago? New Hulk = New Perspective.
The problem with the Hulk is that the longer he continues fighting Thanos the higher the feats will become, and eventually (like a minute) he'll be in dimensional ripping strength range. Ask me how long it took him to reach the strength necessary to open that dimensional partiton. You know what I'll tell you, it took him about 30 seconds.
Did you know that a 2 inch Hulk nearly KO'd a true class 100? Yeah the Abomination nearly took flight when he was hit by a 2 inch Hulk, and that was Professor Hulk.
I see that this can go on and on, but my stance won't change. The Hulk is a threat alone, and he has some pretty potent energy users on his team. Gotta go study.