You mean no flight, super strength, speed, or heat vision just the strength to support their own body weight as normal humans? Thor should win, he weighs over 700 lbs I believe, and has a height, and reach advantage. I think Kal would be terrified of Thor when he realizes that just attempting to budge Thor was hell on earth.
Originally posted by Stoicso height matters in a fight ? tell that to the wolverine writers.
You mean no flight, super strength, speed, or heat vision just the strength to support their own body weight as normal humans? Thor should win, he weighs over 700 lbs I believe, and has a height, and reach advantage. I think Kal would be terrified of Thor when he realizes that just attempting to budge Thor was hell on earth.
and yes no flight no super strength or heat vision. cause that would be part of their powers.
Originally posted by chomperx9
its from all muscle i believe.
Thor is not visually bigger than Herc, that's the problem. Yet he weighs nearly twice as much.
The denser skin/muscle/bone etc argument would make sense, if Thor had greater durability than Herc. But they are about equal.
Hell Superman weighs far less than both of them and his skin is still a lot tougher.
Originally posted by chomperx9i guess it's to late now, but you should have just asked, "who's better at h2h". It's impossible for either man to fight without using their superhuman attributes.
its all about who is a better fighter.
if i gave them only their strength to use everyone would be debating over who is stronger. thats why i took away their strength as well.
Thor wins.
Originally posted by CosmicComet
The denser skin/muscle/bone etc argument would make sense, if Thor had greater durability than Herc. But they are about equal.Hell Superman weighs far less than both of them and his skin is still a lot tougher.
The extra weight comes from his bones, muscle being several times denser than humans etc. His different in that regard from Hercules etc.
I don't agree that Superman's skin is a lot tougher than Thor's. And there's evidence to suggest Thor's more durable than Hercules.