Magneto/Nova Prime/Wonderman vs Superman/Thor

Started by Omega Vision4 pages

Originally posted by carver9
If anyone needs trnasferable feats it should be poloris... everything poloris has done, mags has done it a thousand folds plus interest. Magneto and poloris share the same type of power... this shouldn't even be debated except magneto is far more versatile.

Magneto has defeated a thousand JLAs with interest?

Really do go on.

Originally posted by dmills
Not bad actually. Similar power sets. What's the context though?

I have posted the scans at least 8 times and I don't feel like looking for them but poloris was having split personality issues and was fighting a female version of himself... supes arrives and that's when all of this happens.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Iight.

Thor battle field removing opponents is also a possibility. There isn't what I'd call a high possibility of it happening but it's an option. It's a viable option so to say.

Yea, so him getting into this contest with Mjolnir isn't a good idea.

Imbuing Thor with such an inferior energy would only weaken him. Might as well give him the power of Superman.

Cool beans.

I guess.

Lulz.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Magneto has defeated a thousand JLAs with interest?

Really do go on.

No but mags has soloed the avengers and didn't need a power boost to do this. Magneto is a team buster and he has proven this on so many of occassions.

Originally posted by carver9
No but mags has soloed the avengers and didn't need a power boost to do this. Magneto is a team buster and he has proven this on so many of occassions.
No doubt.

When did the Polaris/Supes fight take place? How many times have they fought?

Originally posted by carver9
No but mags has soloed the avengers and didn't need a power boost to do this. Magneto is a team buster and he has proven this on so many of occassions.

What roster? Few Avengers rosters would equal or surpass the JLA roster Polaris took on.

Same goes for the X-Men.

Originally posted by carver9
No but mags has soloed the avengers and didn't need a power boost to do this. Magneto is a team buster and he has proven this on so many of occassions.

On a list of established comic teams the avengers arent even top 10

Originally posted by Gecko4lif
On a list of established comic teams the avengers arent even top 10
uh oh.

Originally posted by dmills
uh oh.

Shall I go into detail?

I could possibly see an argument made for the Avengers not being in the top 5 (it really depends on which era/version) but they're definitely in the top 10.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
What roster? Few Avengers rosters would equal or surpass the JLA roster Polaris took on.

Same goes for the X-Men.

You all might down play the avengers but writers think of the avengers as being as equal as possible to the jla, that's why they made a comic staring the two in a fight. The avegers in marvel AND dc eyes is just as powerful as the jla. Mags took the down easily, in a couple of panels without breaking a sweat and I feel safe to say that if mags was in dc, he would have soloed the jla as well just like doctor poloris has done along with numerous of other beings.

Going by feats magneto<<poloris so stop ignoring this. Magneto would trample poloris if it came down to a fight between the two.

Again, in dc and marvel eyes, the xmen is a powerful team. Didn't dc and marvel get together to make a story of the two teams fighting and some of the weakest group of the team stalemated the jla and was actually beating some of the core members?

Originally posted by Gecko4lif
Shall I go into detail?
Knock yourself out.

Originally posted by carver9
You all might down play the avengers but writers think of the avengers as being as equal as possible to the jla, that's why they made a comic staring the two in a fight. The avegers in marvel AND dc eyes is just as powerful as the jla. Mags took the down easily, in a couple of panels without breaking a sweat and I feel safe to say that if mags was in dc, he would have soloed the jla as well just like doctor poloris has done along with numerous of other beings.

Going by feats magneto<<poloris so stop ignoring this. Magneto would trample poloris if it came down to a fight between the two.

Again, in dc and marvel eyes, the xmen is a powerful team. Didn't dc and marvel get together to make a story of the two teams fighting and some of the weakest group of the team stalemated the jla and was actually beating some of the core members?

In terms of prestige you are correct. But I think what they're saying is that for the purpose of forum battles JLA > Avengers. How many herald level characters comprise JLA teams? How many on the Avengers?

Originally posted by carver9

Again, in dc and marvel eyes, the xmen is a powerful team. Didn't dc and marvel get together to make a story of the two teams fighting and some of the weakest group of the team stalemated the jla and was actually beating some of the core members?


Nope.

I do recall a X-Men/JLA crossover though where Batman almost soloed an X-Team.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Nope.

I do recall a X-Men/JLA crossover though where Batman almost soloed an X-Team.

Seriously? Damn.

No particular order

God Squad
JLA
Infinity Watch
The authority
Injustice league
Justice society
All star squadron
Green lanterns
The Defenders
Thor corps

etc

Originally posted by dmills
In terms of prestige you are correct. But I think what they're saying is that for the purpose of forum battles JLA > Avengers. How many herald level characters comprise JLA teams? How many on the Avengers?

I agree with that but what I am saying is that in writers eyes, magneto taking on the avengers and the Xmen is just as good as taking on the JLA.

I agree with Gecko... the JLA is more powerful than both groups "on the forum" but that still does not change the fact that Mags has done something that Superman or Thor would NEVER be able to do... solo a high tier team that consist of some of the most powerful beings on the planet. THEN we have a mags that was unable to control his power soling the Avengers yet again that consisted of the Sentry.

I would never argue that The Xmen or the Avengers are equal to the JLA but that still do not change the writers perception of the character.

Place Mags in Doctor Poloris shoes; he would have done far better against the JLA since he is more powerful and has better feats with his powers.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Nope.

I do recall a X-Men/JLA crossover though where Batman almost soloed an X-Team.

I recall that as well but they were not trying to hurt him, they were trying to capture him but he was too agile to catch. Jean Grey read his mind and knew that he was lost in time and that he didnt belong there.

Originally posted by Gecko4lif
No particular order

God Squad
JLA
Infinity Watch
The authority
Injustice league
Justice society
All star squadron
Green lanterns
The Defenders
Thor corps

etc

I agree with this now if it was in a comic books and we asked DC and Marvel to place the Avengers or The Xmen in the 1-10 slot, where would they be "IN WRITERS EYES"?

Originally posted by carver9
I agree with this now if it was in a comic books and we asked DC and Marvel to place the Avengers or The Xmen in the 1-10 slot, where would they be "IN WRITERS EYES"?

Probably top 3 😮

Writers get a nice chubby when thinking about a classic name like the avengers