Originally posted by Ambient
You misunderstand what i meant, i was referring to both Starhawk and Exodus after the sharing/exchanging of thoughts or exp cast by Giselle during your prep, you claimed that they (Exodus and Starhawk) would be able to use magic ala Giselle albeit not as verse as her to which i replied this would not be possible since they would need to acquire a similar magical power source as Giselle which she was only able to garner with the power of the sigil and the absorption of the elders of the magic guilds..
that really doesn't make sense, and isn't in line with the story of Mystic at all. It is always implied that magic comes through training, one of the main stresses when Giselle gets the guild leaders is between her and her sister, because Giselle's sister had worked hard and earned the right to achieve her power, whereas Giselle just had them handed to her. If there is no blockage of the universal energies, which there wouldn't be, they would be able to cast, the mages on Ciress are never implied by anything in the comics to have some special magical “source of energy”, they just have to work hard at it.
Originally posted by Ambient
Sorry man i didn't see anything in there that disprove my claim, in fact you kinda provided me with proof that this spell is mind blowing given that once activated there would be an all out pour of information exchange..Here lets take a look at some of the scans you've provided..
http://img714.imageshack.us/f/31450822.jpg/
Now if what you claim is true that she has full control of the memory being transferred, why then was she not able to limit the info being transfer in her side and save herself the headache?http://img267.imageshack.us/f/75945766.jpg/
In here she actually even plainly said that this spells is mind blowing, in other words overwhelming...Its really quite clear that once this spells is activated, all info is shared at once by the chars. involve..
Really man?
It doesn't matter too much anymore, really. Starhawks "future-memories" are off limits for all purposes, even synapse firing, if that were even suggested (which I've clearly shown it is not). And novice level magic abilities would hardly add any strength to my characters, though unless you have some scans to prove you claims about how magic works in the Cross-Gen universe, they still have them.
Frankly, the scans I've provided speak for themselves, in the first two sets, the only one "overwhelmed" by the spell was an intended victim, and there is obviously much that is not transferred. The Guild leader who first casts it on Giselle was conspiring against her at this time, Giselle was given no hint of this. Giselle knew secrets about the first and various other things, things about the guild her sister was leader of that would have been greatly helpful, there is never any indication she found these out.
Giselle didn't feel anything from the succubus, and it states on panel that she didn't learn much about the man she transferred language into (who never showed any indication of learning anything more about Giselle other than language). And here, just to be overwhelmingly clear:
Mystic 32:
Giselle casts the spell to find out why everyone is fighting:
http://img35.imageshack.us/i/mystic032pg22.jpg/
http://img708.imageshack.us/i/mystic032pg23.jpg/
Mystic 33:
This same individual tells Giselle the story of how magic was blocked on the world:
http://img842.imageshack.us/i/mystic033pg09.jpg/
http://img840.imageshack.us/i/mystic033pg10.jpg/
http://img263.imageshack.us/i/mystic033pg11.jpg/
Thus, not everything is transferred, or Giselle would have already know this. Like I said, it only transfers what the caster wants, in this scene, the context relevant information about the children. She didn't learn all of his memories.
So, ya, I'm entirely right, but it really isn't that important without precog. The magic spells are kinda superfluous