Catfight!: Asajj Ventress vs Lumiya

Who wins this duel?

Force
Lightsabers vs Lightwhip
All Out

Battlesite: Dathomir

Not sure about either of their force ability, seems neither are really that powerful

Id give Lumiya the edge in sabers, Ventress probably never trained to fight against a lightwhip, and that can make a huge difference with exotic weapons.

All out, not sure.

I would give this fight to Lumiya in all 3 facets. She fought Luke to a standstill twice while Kenobi toyed with Ventress.

Didn't Luke eventually get tired of playing games and cut her head off or something?

Lumiya isn't that skilled. She might be able to best Ventress, but some no name Jedi Master was giving her hell in LotF, untill Alema steps in.

No, Luke dominated her in the final of their three fights. Their first two ended in stalemate.

Lumiya and Mara Jade also ended in stale-mate. I would pick her over Assajji who can't even beat padawan anakin.

I believe the only reason anything was a stalemate was because it was a lightwhip. They were not equipped/trained to fight one.

Originally posted by truejedi
Lumiya and Mara Jade also ended in stale-mate. I would pick her over Assajji who can't even beat padawan anakin.

I seem to recall Lumiya having a bomb strapped on during that fight so Mara Jade couldn't just kill her...

wrong fight. Mara fought Lumiya in LOTF, one on one before ship intervened.

and as for the lightwhip thing: Assajji will be just as unprepared.

I'd go with Ventress over Lumiya, personally.

Lumiya isn't that skilled. She might be able to best Ventress, but some no name Jedi Master was giving her hell in LotF, untill Alema steps in.

Whereas Ventress beat Kit Fisto in single combat. And lets not forget that the single best style against a lightwhip is double blades, as Luke showed us.

Lumiya and Mara Jade also ended in stale-mate. I would pick her over Assajji who can't even beat padawan anakin.

It was only a stalemate because Mara was thick enough to engage a cyborg in H2H combat iirc.

NO ALL OF YOU WHO THINK ASAJJ VENTRESS WILL WIN ARE WRONG!!!
Lumiya calls for darth caedus,and caedus pwns ventress

CAEDUS FTW..............

To be continued...

really? To be continued?

Originally posted by 3 fishys
NO ALL OF YOU WHO THINK ASAJJ VENTRESS WILL WIN ARE WRONG!!!
Lumiya calls for darth caedus,and caedus pwns ventress

CAEDUS FTW..............

To be continued...

Originally posted by truejedi
No, Luke dominated her in the final of their three fights. Their first two ended in stalemate.

Lumiya and Mara Jade also ended in stale-mate. I would pick her over Assajji who can't even beat padawan anakin.

but how many people are trained against a lightwhip?
fyi i am glad people here know what a light whip is,in literature and eu many didn't

Are you aware that the set of posters in the SWVF {A} is entirely contained within the set of posters in the Lit/EU section {B}?

That is to say, were you aware that A ∈ B ?

Yeah, we're one group. The PT and OT sections are their own group.

And a group of ign'ant jackasses they are, too.

Spoiler:
we aren't very nice

Spoiler:
they are even worse

To be humble, I'd say I'm about the nicest guy around here. That doesn't say a lot though.