As I see it, most people give Hulk the nod where he'd actually win most of the time. It's just you have people who take "unlimited strength" and "strongest there is" and run with it and assume he's just going to amp and defeat any and everyone short of an abstract being in melee. And if Hulk doesn't win, it's somehow PIS.
My God, people can't even accept Zeus wrecked him in H2H.