It's already been established that when any lantern puts up a shield to protect himself it doesn't hold up very long when hit by a significantly powerful adversary. Beta Ray Bill was able to crack Galactus's helmet with his hammer so it stands to reason that the combined might of Bill, Surfer, and Maxima would be able to at least crack a shield formed from the ring, even if it was only temporary. Once the shield has been cracked Surfer just needs to fill it with the same radiation that is emitted by black Kryptonite before the shield has time to heal itself. Game over.