How Durable is Thor? Thor runs punishment Gauntlet.

Originally posted by abhilegend
What about the high end feats from the attackers? Are you trying to compare thor's high end feats to other characters' averages?

Not the only feat I can use.

If I were to exclusively use Thor's high end feats (not being killed or KO'd when fighting skyfathers and abstracts), even using the best feats of the attackers in this thread, Thor's going to make it quite far.

Okay. To paraphrase from Clark, "swell".

Anyway, my initial response was to the laughable idea that Prime could one shot kill Thor, which is far dumber than Thor, via feats, being capable of making an argument to clear this.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
If I were to exclusively use Thor's high end feats (not being killed or KO'd when fighting skyfathers and abstracts), even using the best feats of the attackers in this thread, Thor's going to make it quite far.

Okay. To paraphrase from Clark, "swell".

Anyway, my initial response was to the laughable idea that Prime could one shot kill Thor, which is far dumber than Thor, via feats, being capable of making an argument to clear this.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Ok.
That's not far from laughable itself considering these guys have feats of beating skyfathers too.

It is laughable when you look at what has actually killed Thor or could have killed him seeing as he's died a few times.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
It is laughable when you look at what has actually killed Thor or could have killed him seeing as he's died a few times.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Yeah, its laughable. You are turning into rage nicely.

Anyone with even passing knowledge on either character can tell you that Prime, while he'd beat Thor, isn't one shot killing him. That's based off of both of their feats. And if you disagree, you fall into one of the follow categories:

A.) An overestimated sense of Prime's capabilities
B.) Lowballing Thor
C.) Ignorant of both characters

or

D.) Trolling

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Anyone with even passing knowledge on either character can tell you that Prime, while he'd beat Thor, isn't one shot killing him. That's based off of both of their feats. And if you disagree, you fall into one of the follow categories:

A.) An overestimated sense of Prime's capabilities
B.) Lowballing Thor
C.) Ignorant of both characters

or

D.) Trolling

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
The on-panel text disagrees with you; the Celestials assault on Thor was described as "merciless."

So you're of the opinion that the Celestials are incapable of killing Thor with their best attacks? What's funny is the Destroyer armor killed him with it's eye beam. So I guess Destroyer armor > Celestials...wait a second...

There's is ZERO chance that Thor is conscious after this gauntlet. Actually, there's a less than zero chance of that. He's been KO'ed by ONE HIT from the Hulk. He's not standing after a more powerful Hulk hits him that many times with him just standing there. No way.

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
There's is ZERO chance that Thor is conscious after this gauntlet. Actually, there's a less than zero chance of that. He's been KO'ed by ONE HIT from the Hulk. He's not standing after a more powerful Hulk hits him that many times with him just standing there. No way.

Oh no doubt he'd be KO'd after 20 non bracing hits from WWH, but I think you and I can agree that despite it being a cheap shot and Mjolnir being involved, that has been the lowest showing Thor's had against a hulk in a very long time if not the lowest period. He just beat an amped WWH and thing not to long ago. and it wasn't inconsistent with the rest of his history. this last showing was.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Oh no doubt he'd be KO'd after 20 non bracing hits from WWH, but I think you and I can agree that despite it being a cheap shot and Mjolnir being involved, that has been the lowest showing Thor's had against a hulk in a very long time if not the lowest period. He just beat an amped WWH and thing not to long ago. and it wasn't inconsistent with the rest of his history. this last showing was.

I agree with you on that point.

I've gone on record many times saying it seems like the current Marvel staff has something against Thor, and it has actually has caused me to stop buying Thor comics. I used to pretty much buy every Thor comic that came out, then we had the Rulk incident, the Taurus incident, the Amadeus Cho incident, Hulk beating Thor into a bloody pulp with his own hammer. Then one shotting Thor with his own hammer. the P5 saga was my last straw for Thor. I'd rather they just stopped putting Thor in comics altogether at this point.

If we look at Thor's showings from only before the JMS run, then I would say Thor could at least make it to SBP in this gauntlet. As it stands for me right now, I highly doubt he's getting past 3.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Oh no doubt he'd be KO'd after 20 non bracing hits from WWH, but I think you and I can agree that despite it being a cheap shot and Mjolnir being involved, that has been the lowest showing Thor's had against a hulk in a very long time if not the lowest period. He just beat an amped WWH and thing not to long ago. and it wasn't inconsistent with the rest of his history. this last showing was.

What did he say before beating this version of Hulk? How did he beat Nul? What happened to him after he beat Nul?

Originally posted by carver9
What did he say before beating this version of Hulk? How did he beat Nul? What happened to him after he beat Nul?

he said he couldn't beat him, then beat him by KO'ing him and putting him in space, then collapsed from being wounded and extended combat. Happy?

Originally posted by carver9
What did he say before beating this version of Hulk? How did he beat Nul? What happened to him after he beat Nul?

A contradictory statement considering he already beat Hulk before.

He one shot BFR him into space.

A weary Thor who had been humilated by both Odin and Cul before fighting amped Hulk and Thing collapsed due to exhaustion.

What's your point? That a less than 100% Thor can take on amped versions of the Hulk and Thing and win? I agree, buddy. 👆

Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
I agree with you on that point.

I've gone on record many times saying it seems like the current Marvel staff has something against Thor, and it has actually has caused me to stop buying Thor comics. I used to pretty much buy every Thor comic that came out, then we had the Rulk incident, the Taurus incident, the Amadeus Cho incident, Hulk beating Thor into a bloody pulp with his own hammer. Then one shotting Thor with his own hammer. the P5 saga was my last straw for Thor. I'd rather they just stopped putting Thor in comics altogether at this point.

If we look at Thor's showings from only before the JMS run, then I would say Thor could at least make it to SBP in this gauntlet. As it stands for me right now, I highly doubt he's getting past 3.

He's had some low moments, but then when you look at what he's done since JMS, I'm really not all that upset about it.

Killed Sentry
Invaded Mephisto's realm and beat the shit out of the Disir
Effected the Chaos King
Staggered Galactus twice
His battle with Glory
Killed the Demogorge
Raped an amped Ulik in moments
No sold Silver Surfer while already injured
Practically one shot killed amped Thing and then one shot BFR Nul
Clipped the Phoenix Force's wings
Resisted the telepathy of P5 Emma Frost

He's had some incredible feats since his rebirth in '07.

His power level is the same as it's always been, imo, but his characterization has been crappy as of late. I suggest reading Aaron's God of Thunder relaunch title, though.

If this is an average Thor, I think the full powered heat vision blasts of the Supermen would be a mother for him to overcome.

KO'd in 3, dead in 6.

Originally posted by Damborgson
he said he couldn't beat him, then beat him by KO'ing him and putting him in space, then collapsed from being wounded and extended combat. Happy?

You do know that Nul hit Thor only once in that fight? Thor pounded on Nul (who wasn't even paying him any attention) and Nul didn't even acknowledge it...a Thor that was trying to kill him. Thor admitting he couldnt beat Hulk is just Thor speaking his mind...that was the reason he bfred him. He tried charged hammer strikes and it did nothing. His only option was to bfr him.

Don't you get tired of lying? Because almost literally everything you posted was a plain out lie. It doesn't help you, or your character so why do it?

Everybody has low-end feats. High-End durability feats for Thor are some of the highest in comics.

There is no way of getting around it.

So, right now, just decide what we are looking at and go from there.

Originally posted by abhilegend
You're misunderstanding me. I never said prime would oneshot kill thor. I find the notion that thor would clear this gauntlet laughable.

I rarely agree with the resident superman clown in the above... but in this case.. I actually do. Maybe i need a break from here..