Water for Elephants.

Started by siriuswriter1 pages

Water for Elephants.

Saw this trailer at imdb...

It's based on a really incredible book, and at least two out of three of the main cast are going to make this movie rock.

Reese Witherspoon and Christoph Waltz, plus Robert Pattinson.

YES, I know. But, watching the trailer, seeing him dressed in regular clothes with his skin a regular human's color, with a subtle Southern accent as per his book counterpart, I am hesitatingly waiting to see if he might be able to possibly start to redeem himself.

Anyway.

TRAILER

Just from that, thumbs up or down?

Thumbs down for me.

Though, in its defense, not really due to any presumptions on how well it is, but just the plot really rubs me the wrong way. I've always hated the "sleep with the other dude's wife but it's okay 'cause its true love" type of storylines.

i may go see this if i am convinced i should

Meant to include this with the first post :

A short summary of the book :

In the late 20's and early 30's, Jon Kakowski, born of two Polish immigrants, is opening his exam to become a veterinarian when he gets called by the Dean, only to learn that his parents have both just died in a car accident. Having no other family, Jon begins to hop trains, then comes up with a plan to jump a circus train. While the "rumblers" decide whether or not to throw him off, the fact is brought up that Jon would be quite capable of becoming the main menagerie vet. During one of his first tasks, taking care of a white pony for a six-horse act, he meets Marlena, who rides the ponies. Her husband seems rather odd when Jon is introduced to him through Marlena, and he spends his time walking the tightrope thin line of being a Performer [and therefore upperclass at the circus] or crew [who are generally looked down upon.

Things take a turn for the dramatic as Jon grows more involved in circus life... and a "very dumb" elephant named Rosie joins the cast. Will he become a permanent part of the act? Or will the pressures of dealing with substandard conditions and a half-crazy Keeper of the Menagerie get him tossed off on the way to the next venue?

[Something I really loved about the book is that it gave all sorts of information about the traveling circus business as it first was. The author's really done her stuff in finding hard to believe circus stories from around this time period and fitting them in, stuff about the freak shows and midway, and codes that circus performers send each other during the show - such as the band playing a certain song when the animals are set loose in the menagerie.]