Saint Of Killers Vs · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

inimalist Junior Member

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thanos also has the power to overide those immune to death.

your argument seems, to me at least, to come from the fact that Thanos is immune to death

well, so is Man-Thing, would he beat SOK?

clearly the intention of my post was not to suggest that Man-Thing is superior to Thanos in any way, in fact, the exact opposite. Man-Thing is a speck compared to these characters, yet shares the same quality it appears you think gives Thanos the win. Thus, you should also agree that characters like Man-Thing, or Mr. Immortal, etc, should beat SOK.

(For the record, I'd say Thanos in all but 1)

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by inimalist
your argument seems, to me at least, to come from the fact that Thanos is immune to death
well, so is Man-Thing, would he beat SOK?
clearly the intention of my post was not to suggest that Man-Thing is superior to Thanos in any way, in fact, the exact opposite. Man-Thing is a speck compared to these characters, yet shares the same quality it appears you think gives Thanos the win. Thus, you should also agree that characters like Man-Thing, or Mr. Immortal, etc, should beat SOK.
(For the record, I'd say Thanos in all but 1)

Thanos has power though which gets the job done here. My point wasn't only that he wins based off of the fact he can't permanently kill him but the power he has on top of it as avatar of death throughout the imperative arc.

King Kandy Senior Member

Originally posted by quanchi112
Sg is a joke character rulk isn't though.
If they had indestructible forms gm wouldn't have died so easily to rulk.
I am unfamiliar with deathurge or what you are talking about hence the issue number or scans comment.

Oh... I don't know the issues but he appeared a lot in Quasar. I don't have the comics any more since my computer went down recently.

inimalist Junior Member

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thanos has power though which gets the job done here. My point wasn't only that he wins based off of the fact he can't permanently kill him but the power he has on top of it as avatar of death throughout the imperative arc.

why does the kill have to be permanent for SOK to win?

Its not like Thanos just gets back up instantly. He was dead for a while after Drax got him, iirc

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by King Kandy
Oh... I don't know the issues but he appeared a lot in Quasar. I don't have the comics any more since my computer went down recently.

I have the entire quasar run on a disk somewhere if you remember the issues I'd look it up but sadly don't have the drive to go on a search myself.

Originally posted by inimalist
why does the kill have to be permanent for SOK to win?
Its not like Thanos just gets back up instantly. He was dead for a while after Drax got him, iirc

I think it was within a reasonable amount of time.

inimalist Junior Member

Issues of Quasar in which Deathurge appears

inimalist Junior Member

Originally posted by quanchi112
I think it was within a reasonable amount of time.

he didn't get back up and continue fighting. Forum rules, thats a W afaik...

Whether thanos gets up in 15 min or 15 hours, its long enough that its a KO

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by inimalist
Issues of Quasar in which Deathurge appears

Which issue do they describe as him indestructible ? I read the cosmos in collision years ago but can't remember the finer details if it was in that arc.

inimalist Junior Member

hold on, I think I have them on my pc...

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by inimalist
hold on, I think I have them on my pc...

K.

TricksterPriest Renegade Timelord

I notice you're still dodging the question. You're the guy who brought it up, so why not man up and answer me.

Can the Spear of Destiny kill Thanos?

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
I notice you're still dodging the question. You're the guy who brought it up, so why not man up and answer me.
Can the Spear of Destiny kill Thanos?

Even if it does which I am not saying Thanos comes right back since he's in an indestructible form.

TricksterPriest Renegade Timelord

It can permanently kill abstracts. Hell, it can permanently kill Spectre. Thanos is that powerful? Seriously? 🤨

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
It can permanently kill abstracts. Hell, it can permanently kill Spectre. Thanos is that powerful? Seriously? 🤨

Thanos is an anomaly and is powered by an abstract. I have answered your question so please without further adieu let's get back to the topic.

inimalist Junior Member

Deathurge (and I totally forget the relevance of this already):

Turns out he is the messenger/herald/avatar of Oblivion, not Death:

Quasar 2:

He is immune to damage from anyone who doesn't have the will to live:

Quasar 2:

Quasar does manage to use his powers to have some effect on Deathurge, no real damage done:

Quasar 2:

Though even if he does damage to Deathurge, it is non-fatal and regenerated instantly:

Quasar 39:

He is also completely immune to the penance stare:

Quasar 23:

TricksterPriest Renegade Timelord

This weapon can kill abstracts.

BullwinkleMoose Senior Member

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thanos is immune to death until proven otherwise. Sure, he can die but that doesn't mean he can't come right back.

LOL, Quan doesn't think Presence can kill Thanos and prevent him from coming back.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by inimalist
Deathurge [b](and I totally forget the relevance of this already):
Turns out he is the messenger/herald/avatar of Oblivion, not Death:
Quasar 2:
He is immune to damage from anyone who doesn't have the will to live:
Quasar 2:
Quasar does manage to use his powers to have some effect on Deathurge, no real damage done:
Quasar 2:
Though even if he does damage to Deathurge, it is non-fatal and regenerated instantly:
Quasar 39:
He is also completely immune to the penance stare:
Quasar 23:
[/B]

Ok, I was confused with the death remark and knew oblivion backed maelstrom in cosmos but for the most part don't see him as an equal to Thanos in terms of position or feats by any means. Do we agree on that much ?

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
This weapon can kill abstracts.

Not Thanos.

inimalist Junior Member

Originally posted by quanchi112
Ok, I was confused with the death remark and knew oblivion backed maelstrom in cosmos but for the most part don't see him as an equal to Thanos in terms of position or feats by any means. Do we agree on that much ?

Deathurge? no, of course not

I think you just wanted some proof he was indestructable.

iirc his GLA appearances even support this

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by inimalist
Deathurge? no, of course not
I think you just wanted some proof he was indestructable.
iirc his GLA appearances even support this

Ok, my position isn't that Thanos isn't the only one is is immune to death but with the power he has along with this he beats sok.