The Comedian vs Luc Deveraux

vs.

The Comedian from the Watchmen film, Luc Deveraux from Universal Soldier 1-3

H2H fight, two scenarios:

1. Fight in the middle of the street, no weapons.

2. Setting is in a warehouse. Anything can be used as weapon.

AND

3. Both of them get their standard Equipment and Weapons.

Who wins each scenario?

Hard call. Old Comedian held his own for a little bit against Veidt. I'd imagine a young comedian would be a beast. So him in H2H.

Again, probably Comedian.

Could go either way. Prob Luc.

.

Tough call.

Everything Robtard said/

An old Comedian holding up without being kicked like a ragdoll against Ozymodias is an incredible warrior. But it's also uncertain if he was that skilled at the moment of the OP photo.

Originally posted by Robtard
Hard call. Old Comedian held his own for a little bit against Veidt. I'd imagine a young comedian would be a beast. So him in H2H.

Again, probably Comedian.

Could go either way. Prob Luc.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Can't remember if it was depicted or mentioned in the movie, but in the comic at least a young (well middle aged) Comedian did beat a young Ozymandias in h/h. So yeah he was a beast.

Not in the theatrical release and I don't think in the extended version either.

The comic, Veidt also said he was inexperienced at the time.

Still though, 60+ yer old man taking the beating he did and from Veidt, dude's an animal.

GR-44.

Comedian, easily.

Dude's a total beast. He will break his neck like a ****ing plastic spoon.

Edward Blake.

You know that part where th Comedian got thrown out of a building and died. Yeah the Unisol's woulda probably walked that off.

The point is Ol'Comedian punches, kicks, stabs, runs over GR 44, til he can't do so no more, Luc's dead eyes look almost curiously at his attacker for as long as it takes Deveraux to put his fist through Blake's head.

Luc could run 30 MPH while pushing ans SUV, smash threw walls, we saw UniSols get shot repeatedly and walk it off. He also displayed more fighting skill then Blake.

So Luc is Stronger, Tougher, and more skilled. The only advantage that Comedian may have is that he is faster in terms of fighting and even that's debatable.

That's like your opinion, man.

And his opinion rings true.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
And his opinion rings true.

Get your tongue out his *******, RJ.

Jealous?

one beats up women and one beats up cybernetic Goldberg and Michael Jai White.

haermm