Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows II

Started by the ninjak5 pages

Spoiler:
By killing the last anchor to the physical world being the snake.

Voldemort dissipated away. Harry was one too but he died earlier

Terrible loophole writing. Needed to be more fleshed out.

Spoiler:
I killed him

seriously bad writing

Originally posted by the ninjak
Spoiler:
By killing the last anchor to the physical world being the snake.

Voldemort dissipated away. Harry was one too but he died earlier

Terrible loophole writing. Needed to be more fleshed out.

I agree. It was just a matter of time at that point but I have heard differently.

Merged.

Yep, another **** up in the movie. The book is quite clear that Harry was responsible for his death, but in the movie he just fades away when Nagini is killed. Terrible, terrible writing.

Originally posted by ares834
Yep, another **** up in the movie. The book is quite clear that Harry was responsible for his death, but in the movie he just fades away when Nagini is killed. Terrible, terrible writing.
Well wasn't Nagini the last piece of his soul so it does make sense that once that's destroyed his body cannot sustain itself anymore.

No. His body still has a part of his soul as well... Hell, what do you think that spirit in the first movie was? It was the bit of his soul that was not in a horcrux. And then of course we have Voldemort in the fourth movie.

Originally posted by ares834
No. His body still has a part of his soul as well... Hell, what do you think that spirit in the first movie was? It was the bit of his soul that was not in a horcrux. And then of course we have Voldemort in the fourth movie.
I figured when his original body was destroyed that piece of his soul was lost forever so this body didn't have any part of his soul and was relying on the other horcruxes.

That's not what happens. Your soul isn't destroyed when your body is. Hermione says this in the books and I'm fairly sure she mentions it in DH part 1. Plus as I said we see Voldy's spirit in TSS.

Originally posted by ares834
That's not what happens. Your soul isn't destroyed when your body is. Hermione says this in the books and I'm fairly sure she mentions it in DH part 1. Plus as I said we see Voldy's spirit in TSS.
His soul was already split up in so many parts it was just a small piece of it anyways. The movies differentiate from the books I mean Voldemort can't even feel horcruxes being destroyed whereas in the movies he feels it. Why else would he disintegrate if he had a piece of his soul in his own body when the snake died ?

No, I agree that is what's happening. It's just stupid and contradicts what is otherwise presented in the movies.

Originally posted by ares834
No, I agree that is what's happening. It's just stupid and contradicts what is otherwise presented in the movies.
It did seem out of place and Harry specifically mentions killing the snake and then it's just those two left. Overall this was my favorite harry potter flick.

It would be my favourite, if not for Voldemort going all retarded with his "Avada Kedavra" sounding more like El Mundo than some badass Dark Wizard. Even people in the theatre were laughing. :/

At that point I just felt like throwing up!

Never read the books, this one is my fav HP movie.

Originally posted by Makashidude
It would be my favourite, if not for Voldemort going all retarded with his "Avada Kedavra" sounding more like El Mundo than some badass Dark Wizard. Even people in the theatre were laughing. :/
I liked when he screamed Avada Kedvara.

Originally posted by The Nuul
Never read the books, this one is my fav HP movie.

I read the books but this is my favorite movie of all of the HP. 🙂