HP Doomsday VS Mangog

Started by rotiart3 pages
Originally posted by quanchi112
the president is physically superior to thanos.

He controls the almighty pen... And an eraser!
.... :-P

Originally posted by rotiart
He controls the almighty pen... And an eraser!
.... :-P
Taking things way too far, brah.

Originally posted by YoungGunna
Plus the OP never said we were using SA Mangog but you guys continue to

The OP never said current Mangog as well.Current would get wreck by HP Doomsday because of the obvious nerfing.

Originally posted by YoungGunna
Your using ABC logic Plus that wasn't HP doomsday Imperiex killed
Mangog lost to classic Thor and was taking orders from classic Thanos
Get out of here man

You're acting as if Thanos can't permanently kill Doomsday.The fact the Cosmic Entity Death chose Thanos as her Avatar, already says Thanos would kill Doomsday permanently since Thanos was killing beings that belonged to a universe were Death is defeated.Saying "No!Thanos can't permanently kill Doomsday because he'll just come back and adapt to pawn Thanos" is like saying Doomsday is immune to the Cosmic Entity Death.

Originally posted by Igniz
The OP never said current Mangog as well.Current would get wreck by HP Doomsday because of the obvious nerfing.

You're acting as if Thanos can't permanently kill Doomsday.The fact the Cosmic Entity Death chose Thanos as her Avatar, already says Thanos would kill Doomsday permanently since Thanos was killing beings that belonged to a universe were Death is defeated.Saying "No!Thanos can't permanently kill Doomsday because he'll just come back and adapt to pawn Thanos" is like saying Doomsday is immune to the Cosmic Entity Death.

Thanos can't kill DD period. DD is far to durable to even sustain any damage. Even if DD did receive damage it would not only be small but healed back up almost instantaneously.

Also, HP DD can adapt in mid battle to counter any attack. The only way to kill him is to one shot him. Not even Imperiex can one shot HP DD. For the intentions of HP DD was that he was beyond death and no force in the universe could end him, except the end of time. This was clearly writer's intentions.

Originally posted by h1a8
Thanos can't kill DD period. DD is far to durable to even sustain any damage. Even if DD did receive damage it would not only be small but healed back up almost instantaneously.

Also, HP DD can adapt in mid battle to counter any attack. The only way to kill him is to one shot him. Not even Imperiex can one shot HP DD. For the intentions of HP DD was that he was beyond death and no force in the universe could end him, except the end of time. This was clearly writer's intentions.

Imperiex did oneshot hp DD with his attack. LOL.

The writer flat out stated you are wrong and that even superman at 95 percent power could physically kill him. Everything you say is flat out denied by the writer himself.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Imperiex did oneshot hp DD with his attack. LOL.

The writer flat out stated you are wrong and that even superman at 95 percent power could physically kill him. Everything you say is flat out denied by the writer himself.

He did not one shot HP DD. He never met HP DD.

Is Jurgens Mangog the same as Silver Age Mangog? No it isn't.
And neither is Jurgens DD the same as Loeb DD.

First of all, I don't believe the writer of Hunter Prey said Superman at 95% could kill HP DD. Who ever said that is either on drugs or Superman operates at far under 95% the vast majority of the time.

Second, I don't go by writer's opinions but what is shown on panel.

Originally posted by h1a8
I don't go by writer's opinions but what is shown on the versus forum.

Originally posted by h1a8
Thanos can't kill DD period. DD is far to durable to even sustain any damage. Even if DD did receive damage it would not only be small but healed back up almost instantaneously.

Also, HP DD can adapt in mid battle to counter any attack. The only way to kill him is to one shot him. Not even Imperiex can one shot HP DD. For the intentions of HP DD was that he was beyond death and no force in the universe could end him, except the end of time. This was clearly writer's intentions.

😆 😆 😆 Your post makes wanna make a thread.The title would be "Is Doomsday immune to the Cosmic Entity Death?"The problem with Thanos is that if you fight him, you'll also be fighting the one he worships as evidenced in the Thanos Imperative.As for this thread, how can HP DD stop Mangog from feeding on his rage?If you're gonna say HP DD will adapt and become stronger, the same goes for Mangog as the fight goes on.

Originally posted by h1a8
He did not one shot HP DD. He never met HP DD.

Is Jurgens Mangog the same as Silver Age Mangog? No it isn't.
And neither is Jurgens DD the same as Loeb DD.

First of all, I don't believe the writer of Hunter Prey said Superman at 95% could kill HP DD. Who ever said that is either on drugs or Superman operates at far under 95% the vast majority of the time.

Second, I don't go by writer's opinions but what is shown on panel.

Yes, he met the same character and the writer stated point blank that doomsday can be physically killed by superman.

Every writer puts a different spin on a character but we take the entire body of work.

You yourself brought up the writer's intentions so you just exposed yourself a post later by disregarding the writer's opinion. You're wrong and have never read it anyways.

Originally posted by h1a8
I believe DD can break Superman's jaw with a punch.

Yes DOS Superman and DOS DD was mid tier in strength.

And I am full of shyt as you said.

I just believe DOS DD is invincible and unbeatable. Superman beating him was PIS. 😂

But based off feats Silver Age Mangog should beat all DD except HP (stalemate there unless DD evolves something to gain an upper edge). Current Mangog dies though.

Lol.

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
If Zod could do it.. I have no doubt a bloodlusted Thor with Mjolnir could

No doubt, but rivals don't often break bones at that level. They could of course -Thor was breaking Hulk's bones at one point- but not the norm.

Originally posted by Igniz
😆 😆 😆 Your post makes wanna make a thread.The title would be "Is Doomsday immune to the Cosmic Entity Death?"The problem with Thanos is that if you fight him, you'll also be fighting the one he worships as evidenced in the Thanos Imperative.As for this thread, how can HP DD stop Mangog from feeding on his rage?If you're gonna say HP DD will adapt and become stronger, the same goes for Mangog as the fight goes on.

What you don't know is that Thor koed a later version of Mangog with physical force with ONE BLOW. HP DD destroys current Mangog. Silver Age Mangog would be a different fight all together.

Second, Thanos had the power to keep things dead, provided he is able to kill them. Now if Thanos is able to kill HP DD then yes I can believe he may stay dead. But I don't believe that Thanos can kill DD let alone do more damage than what the OE done (which was nothing).

Originally posted by the Darkone
SA Mangog works HP Doomsday!

Regular Mangog has to work for it more!

SA Mangog is the "regular" Mangog.

His most recent flopping is just another side effect of Marvel's current "Age of the Fanboy" writing.