Haldir (from Helms Deep) vs Achiles

Instead of Hector, Alchiles faces Haldir. Both are in their respective armor and wielding swords only. So who wins? The Elf who fought in the 1st War of the Ring and racked up a high body count before being killed at Helms Deep or the legendary Greek warrior was said to be unbeatable?

One of the best archers in Middle Earth vs a man whose one weakness is an arrow to the ankle?

Anyone else laughing?

Originally posted by Darth Truculent
wielding swords only

Achiles wins.

Haldir didn't do much in the films that compares with Achilles, be it with sword or bow. Fancy elf-boy goes down.

Originally posted by siriuswriter
One of the best archers in Middle Earth vs a man whose one weakness is an arrow to the ankle?

Anyone else laughing?

And he would know to shoot at the ankle because...? Not like it matters in this thread.

Yeah, Haldir goes down like a b*tch.

Just noting, it seems ironic to me. 😄