Spiderman (no webbing) vs. Logan (no claws)

Started by Gadabout10 pages

Spiderman (no webbing) vs. Logan (no claws)

Spiderman w/o his webbing vs. Wolverine w/o his claws
Fight takes place in Central Park
Speed and power vs. blunt force and regeneration-who wins

No webbing even to swing onto different edifices in the park?

Logan. He's taken harder hits than Parker's and kept going, and even if he can't drop Spidey with one blow, he can win a battle of attrition. He's skilled enough to tag Spidey (especially with no SS), and he'll do damage when he does.

Parkers no slouch in durability, he's taken hits from Hulk. The lack of claws really hurt Wolverines damage output here.

Even if Logan can take more, a LOT more, Spidey has a pretty significant agility edge over him.

Enough to go against entire teams and do well, like the Fantastic Four and the Xmen (And a lot of what he did in those encounters could be done without his webbing, if not all of it, like webbing up Sue Richards)

True, but Spidey still can't really do anything to drop Logan here. With no webbing, he can't even take wins via incapicitation.

Claws lower Wolverine's damage output insofar as he can't one-shot Parker with one well placed blow. Adamantium-weighted blows are still going to take their toll on Spidey, and with no precog, chances are that he'll be feeling a lot of them.

Spidey's got the speed/mobility edge, but at some point, he's going to have to take the battle to Logan to land some blows. This battle doesn't favor him because he'd have to essentially wail on Logan for an extended period to drop him.

Originally posted by Harbinger
True, but Spidey still can't really do anything to drop Logan here. With no webbing, he can't even take wins via incapicitation.

Claws lower Wolverine's damage output insofar as he can't one-shot Parker with one well placed blow. Adamantium-weighted blows are still going to take their toll on Spidey, and with no precog, chances are that he'll be feeling a lot of them.

Spidey's got the speed/mobility edge, but at some point, he's going to have to take the battle to Logan to land some blows. This battle doesn't favor him because he'd have to essentially wail on Logan for an extended period to drop him.

True, although Spidey's done ok against comparably reinforced characters.

But, any chance Spidey can take a few just flat out overpowering him? Wrestle him to the ground and wail on him or something?

Is it something he'd do in a comic for even 1 or 2 wins? (I remember him using a strangle hold on Fisk. That might not go well for Logan, unless he doesn't need to breath.)

True but I just read the "True but" parts of everyone's post and I agree that Spider-Man wins.

Originally posted by cdtm
True, although Spidey's done ok against comparably reinforced characters.

But, any chance Spidey can take a few just flat out overpowering him? Wrestle him to the ground and wail on him or something?

Is it something he'd do in a comic for even 1 or 2 wins? (I remember him using a strangle hold on Fisk. That might not go well for Logan, unless he doesn't need to breath.)

IMO, Peter would have to cut loose to take some wins given the stips here. Then, he could potentially bull rush Logan and start wailing on him. But hell, even then it might not work given the skeleton. Wolvie's routinely taken blows from guys well above his weight class and not been KOed, so Spidey's nothing he hasn't dealt with before. Given that, I don't see Spidey being able to "overpower" Logan.

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
True but I just read the "True but" parts of everyone's post and I agree that Spider-Man wins.
lol

An angry Spiderman has already wailed on Wolverine with no effect.

He's also wailed on him with effect and tossed him out of a window.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
tossed him out of a window.
not relevant here

Originally posted by carver9
An angry Spiderman has already wailed on Wolverine with no effect.

He had an effect.

"He's starting to get the message and stay down. But I can't wipe that smirk off his face.", is the jist of it.

Wasn't Peter beating Logan's head into a headstone at the time?

Originally posted by carver9
An angry Spiderman has already wailed on Wolverine with no effect.

could someone post a scan?

Originally posted by cdtm
He had an effect.

"He's starting to get the message and stay down. But I can't wipe that smirk off his face.", is the jist of it.

I'm referring to marvel knights #13.

Originally posted by carver9
I'm referring to marvel knights #13.

The one where spidy gets mad about wolverine "hitting on" mary jane?

i remember that fight wolverine won via claws.

Originally posted by BlackZero30x
The one where spidy gets mad about wolverine "hitting on" mary jane?

i remember that fight wolverine won via claws.

I just noticed your gamertag.

If someone sends you tasteful pictures of their anus and balls then just let it happen. It's just nature

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
I just noticed your gamertag.

If someone sends you tasteful pictures of their anus and balls then just let it happen. It's just nature

haha! well they say you can't fight nature.....

Btw does anyone have scans of people hurting themselves punching logan. I mean come on throwing a couple of shots to Logan's skull by a 10 tonner with an average durability lower than his output (which btw is hitting with much more force than 10 tons as it isn't a press lift) should break spidey's hand. The small Canadian takes it unless Spidey wants this to turn into a stalemate where he drops from exhaustion.

Spider-Man can strangle him. Logan is nowhere strong enough to free himself.

He can also throw Logan a few times against a wall. That will slow him down, and he can strangle him afterwards.

Or he places a bulldozer on him.

Lots of options actuall.

Really, Logan without his claws is nothing special, but Spider-Man without his web is still more dangerous.