AotC Anakin Skywalker Versus Darth Maul

Setting is Theed Palace.

Darth Maul waits behind the large door to confront Obi-Wan and Jinn - only to find AotC Anakin standing there, instead.

Maul shrugs and ignites his lightsaber.

1. Force

2. Sabers

3. Anything goes, kids.

😉

Who wins this?

Personally, I'd take Maul in all three scenarios.

Maul would stomp him.

My general distain for AOTC Anakin has not diminished. He's out of his depth here imo.

The argument has successfully been made before that Anakin could best TMP Obi-Wan, and Anakin did hold out very well against Count Dooku, who is more skilled and powerful than Maul.

Plus at this stage, Anakin has powerful, developing abilities.

"Developing"' is a key word here though. Not quite yet developed to take Maul down.

Either way, it would probably be close.

Agreed.

You think Maul is a good match for Vader but it'd be close with AOTC Anakin? lol, no.

How does that contradict what I said?
Maul is a good match for Anakin in sabers, and he is a good match for Vader in sabers. In both cases he wins (save for RotS Anakin of course)

Spoiler:
U Silly Brit

AOTC Anakin sucks chode. 😬

You seriously underestimate Darth Vader.

Originally posted by Nephthys
AOTC Anakin sucks chode. 😬

You seriously underestimate Darth Vader.

LOL.

Originally posted by Nephthys
You seriously underestimate Darth Vader.

Nah.
Vader will be beaten by Maul in sabers only. And it would be close.
In the force and all-out though, I have no doubt that Vader will mop the floor with the Zabrak.

No, he won't. Vader has vastly superior lightsaber feats to Maul. A few measly weeks after his mutilation and he's blitzing jedi with absurd ease. He pretty much invented his own lightsaber style. In Shadow Hunter Maul had trouble with a padawan in straight combat.

It just cracks me up that you think Vader is on the same level as AOTC Ani. No freaking way dude.

Yeah, no.

I think you underestimate Maul a bit.

And AotC Anakin is not on the same level as Vader, do not imply I said that 🙂

O RLY?

Maul is a good match for Anakin in sabers, and he is a good match for Vader in sabers. In both cases he wins

Seems like it to me. 😬

ya, really 😉

The thing is Vader destroys Maul easily in the force, so in all-out scenario Maul will have no chance to really threaten the Dark Lord. Only in sabers he can do that.
On the other hand AotC Anakin will lose to Maul either way.

C'mon do I really have to explain that to you? 🙂

......In lightsabers.

facepalm

Oh my....

Because Maul > AotC Anakin in sabes and Maul > Vader in sabers
it does not mean that AotC Anakin = Vader in sabers.

My opinion that Maul will win with either one of them in sabers does not make them equal in that department.

Capiche?

Originally posted by Nephthys
No, he won't. Vader has vastly superior lightsaber feats to Maul. A few measly weeks after his mutilation and he's blitzing jedi with absurd ease. He pretty much invented his own lightsaber style. In Shadow Hunter Maul had trouble with a padawan in straight combat.

👆

It just cracks me up that you think Vader is on the same level as AOTC Ani. No freaking way dude.

😆