Walter with Tanaraq wins
Soul attack
http://i26.photobucket.com/albums/c120/A_Flight2/AlphaFlight23-16.jpg
Originally posted by leonidas
^ hmm, we've seen proof that a god's 'soul' is different from a mortals'. i obviously can't say for certain, but i have doubts that that type of attack would put herc down. hurt? sure, probably, but i think it would come down to a physical battle still and herc's odds are good.
Talisman isn't mortal, even gods/goddess bow to her. That attack didn't take out Talisman, but if Tanaraq kepted doing it would have.
Depends on how much Tanaraq boost his strength, as even mentioned in the handbook Walter's strength is dynamic.
Originally posted by -K-M-
Talisman isn't mortal, even gods/goddess bow to her. That attack didn't take out Talisman, but if Tanaraq kepted doing it would have.Depends on how much Tanaraq boost his strength, as even mentioned in the handbook Walter's strength is dynamic.
not saying she isn't special, but she isn't a 'god', her soul isn't a 'god's soul'. we've seen that thor's soul is special because it is immortal. i still think there is a difference, but again, i have no real proof the attack wouldn't work, just grounds for doubting it would be as impactful.
as for walter's strength--it's why i rarely get into threads with him. he seems to be all over the place. let's say that it's at its peak for this fight though. is there a version of sasquatch/tanaraq that you think is strong enough to kill herc in straight h2h?
Originally posted by leonidas
not saying she isn't special, but she isn't a 'god', her soul isn't a 'god's soul'. we've seen that thor's soul is special because it is immortal. i still think there is a difference, but again, i have no real proof the attack wouldn't work, just grounds for doubting it would be as impactful.as for walter's strength--it's why i rarely get into threads with him. he seems to be all over the place. let's say that it's at its peak for this fight though. is there a version of sasquatch/tanaraq that you think is strong enough to kill herc in straight h2h?
They have refered her as a "goddess" before.
*shrugs* It's possible, but I dont know hence why I went with the soul attack. He could also cast illuisions or summon Surtur's army, etc. He's more then just physical strength. If it was true Tanaraq yeah definetly I can see him physically beating Hercules, but a Tanaraq amped Walter?I don't know. However, considering how well the Wrecking Crew did against BRB when they were amped by Tanaraq I wouldnt put it past him
meh, fair enuff. my initial instinct was that both would take some. i'd give herc a slight majority, but if tanaraq is using other powers maybe it would go the other way or be a split. i've always found walter to be a confusing character tbh. i liked him when he first came onto the scene. much simpler....
