Jedi Order Showdown

Yep. Jacen stomped Kyle pretty hard in LotF.

Originally posted by Vorpal Ruin
I think Corran has better dueling feats than any of them, except Jacen.

You spit in Luke's face if you consider Jacen his finest apprentice.

At their peak while within the order.

Jacen/Caedus becomes one of the most powerful of the NJO, if not second to Luke.

I consider that to be the "finest."

Yep. Jacen stomped Kyle pretty hard in LotF.

Neph asked about Jaina, not Jacen.

Jaina's not even a master, and she wouldn't have been able to stand against Caedus without Luke's help.

Originally posted by Korto Vos
Jacen/Caedus becomes one of the most powerful of the NJO, if not second to Luke.
I consider that to be the "finest."

Jacen Solo was one of Luke's biggest failures. Finest at one point, in TUF, sure. Overall? Failure. His brother was the shining example of what Luke wanted to instill in his training.

If "finest" = most powerful, then I couldn't disagree. That isn't all there is to be a jedi though.

Originally posted by Korto Vos
Neph asked about Jaina, not Jacen.

Sure. And Jaina holds her own against Jacen.

Originally posted by truejedi
Jaina's not even a master, and she wouldn't have been able to stand against Caedus without Luke's help.

Nor is Jacen for the matter. And she fared quite well against him the second time.

Sith Lord > Jedi Master. But I get your point.

Spoiler:
Though if he counts as a real Sith Lord is another story.

Jaina holding her own against him is iffy. Iirc he really didn't want to kill her and was really distracted by various things and was being f'ed with by Luke to booooot.

you mean when he only had one arm, and didn't have time to fight her? really?

oh yeah and he had one arm

which means he was already down TWO hands. you try to fight while missing two hands.

Originally posted by truejedi
you mean when he only had one arm, and didn't have time to fight her? really?

Yep, however, I have no doubt that Jacen was doing all he could to escape/defeat her so he could warn Allana.

Hmm... Now I'm wondering how Mara Jade would stack up against Jaina and Kyle.

Mara is the Batman of Starwars so ooooobviously she'd win.

I think Mara v Jaina would be a good match.