Who has the best striking feats?

Originally posted by The Sorrow
It was confirmed on panel fairly recently Hulk hits harder than Thor (and Hercules).

Yea, I think I need to nip this in the bud before it spreads.

According to Korg, Green Scar -while enraged- hits slightly harder than Thor. Seeing as how Korg wasn't hit with anything resembling Thor's best and got tagged by like a glancing blow, the scene isn't something I would champion if I was a Hulk fan.

Using that instance to give Hulk the nod over Thor in such a thread is laughable after the most basic analyses.

On the other hand, Thor collided with an amped up Green Scar, and turned him into the first green satellite.

mindset's sig

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
On the other hand, Thor collided with an amped up Green Scar, and turned him into the first green satellite.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Yea, I think I need to nip this in the bud before it spreads.

^ and that was a written-down hulk too ermm

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Yea, I think I need to nip this in the bud before it spreads.

According to Korg, Green Scar -while enraged- hits slightly harder than Thor. Seeing as how Korg wasn't hit with anything resembling Thor's best and got tagged by like a glancing blow, the scene isn't something I would champion if I was a Hulk fan.

Using that instance to give Hulk the nod over Thor in such a thread is laughable after the most basic analyses.

On the other hand, Thor collided with an amped up Green Scar, and turned him into the first green satellite.

He knocked Nul away with more than a physical strike and KO'ed himself in the process, not really a great showing for Thor in all honesty

Thor fought an amped Hulk and Thing to a standstill.

Deal with it guys.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
Add: Thor BFRed Hulk (via Mjölnir) cause he knew he couldn't **** with him face to face.

Oh did he know?

I am curious why you believe Thor intended to battle field remove the Hulk.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
I am curious why you believe Thor intended to battle field remove the Hulk.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Thor fought an amped Hulk and Thing to a standstill.

Deal with it guys.

Oh did he know?

I am curious why you believe Thor intended to battle field remove the Hulk.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
thor made it quite clear

Not really.

Thor has always taken the Hulk head on. Even in that very story despite the odds being stacked against him. It was far from clear that battle field removal was his intent, and not simply a byproduct of his blow.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
I don't have a problem with Thor taking on both of them, the thing that bugs me is that you complain about people blowing stuff out of proportion (Korg statement) [can't comment on that because I haven't seen the instance] but in the same post try to make it sound that Thor punched Hulk into the stratusphere, while he actually used his Hammer's exotic powers to get rid off him.

I'm not sure if you're serious. I said this:

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
On the other hand, Thor collided with an amped up Green Scar, and turned him into the first green satellite.

I wouldn't call it exotic. Thor charged up his hammer like he's done on various occasions. Just to be clear, Thor spun his hammer and was radiating energy. I hope that's clear enough for you. 🙂

Originally posted by The Sorrow
Who said he was enraged?
Are you going by their original fight? If so then your reading to much into it. He stated first hand Hulk hits harder than Thor and he has been hit by both. End of really.

The comic? I specifically recall him being ticked off by Korg while pounding him.

Yes I am, because in the flash back you referenced, Thor didn't even hit Korg. He was busy running away while Thor ripped his fellow Kronans to pieces.

Not really. You can use that scene to argue that Green Scar has the edge when pissed on average but no more than that. Arguing that the scene is enough to give Hulk the nod over Thor in such a thread is just too far.

Fun fact: When Thor got ticked off, he one shot killed Kronans in a later story.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Not really.

Thor has always taken the Hulk head on. Even in that very story despite the odds being stacked against him. It was far from clear that battle field removal was his intent, and not simply a byproduct of his blow.

I read it as BFR as a result of the blow. But from Thor's little speech, I can see how some could believe that it was intentional.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
that only makes thor look worse *shrug*

In what sense? Whatever, it doesn't matter.

My point is that I'm not sure battle field removal was he intent. It's definitely possible but it just seems like an odd way to go about it, and he always tries to take the Hulk down head on.

Fraction was a bit unclear with what was going through Thor's head during the sequence.

Originally posted by dmills
I read it as BFR as a result of the blow. But from Thor's little speech, I can see how some could believe that it was intentional.

👆

Originally posted by dmills
I read it as BFR as a result of the blow. But from Thor's little speech, I can see how some could believe that it was intentional.

Pretty much my stance.

I just find it weird that Thor would charge him head on, if the admission was an admission of inferiority.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
The comic? I specifically recall him being ticked off by Korg while pounding him.

Yes I am, because in the flash back you referenced, Thor didn't even hit Korg. He was busy running away while Thor ripped his fellow Kronans to pieces.

Not really. You can use that scene to argue that Green Scar has the edge when pissed on average but no more than that. Arguing that the scene is enough to give Hulk the nod over Thor in such a thread is just too far.

Fun fact: When Thor got ticked off, he one shot killed Kronans in a later story.

I just disagree with going back decades to the original fight. It was re-told and Korg stated Hulk hits a bit harder, Banner also said he was stronger than Hercules in the following issue iirc and he is roughly equal to Thor. Seems as though that's Marvel view on things.

After re-watching the scan it seems that I stand corrected, there was somekind of lightning that could/should be Hulks line of flight while I thought first time Thor just BFRed him via teleport.

The fight recently involving Hulk and Thor was a plot. The story was meant to show Thor pounding on Hulk with the ending resulting being "no matter how powerful you THINK you are Thor...your best don't mean sh** to Hulk.". Then we get confirmation of this when Thor admits he can't do a thing to Hulk. The writers intent was quite clear. Then we have Thor passing out whereas Hulk was thrown out of space, circled the planet and then crash landed head first onto the planet without a scratch whereas Thor was still knocked the hell out. Hulk got up and is still fighting after all of that.

The writers intent is pretty clear cut to me.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
After re-watching the scan it seems that I stand corrected, there was somekind of lightning that could/should be Hulks line of flight while I thought first time Thor just BFRed him via teleport.

👆

I was wondering if you were sure about Thor using MJOLNIR's exotic abilities.

Originally posted by carver9
The fight recently involving Hulk and Thor was a plot. The story was meant to show Thor pounding on Hulk with the ending resulting being "no matter how powerful you THINK you are Thor...your best don't mean sh** to Hulk.". Then we get confirmation of this when Thor admits he can't do a thing to Hulk. The writers intent was quite clear. Then we have Thor passing out whereas Hulk was thrown out of space, circled the planet and then crash landed head first onto the planet without a scratch whereas Thor was still knocked the hell out. Hulk got up and is still fighting after all of that.

The writers intent is pretty clear cut to me.

It IS an amped Hulk though.

.