Marv (Sin city) vs. Scar (AvP)

An unblooded predator (Scar) is stalking some random thugs in Sin City, trying to determine if they are worthy prey. His train of thought is interrupted when Marv kills them all in fifteen seconds with his fist's for insulting some chick an hour ago.

Impressed, the unblooded decides that he shall take Marv's skull.

The Predator is disarmed. It's complete hand to hand combat and all fists.

Who survives?

Scar.

Scar, easy.

It would be a good fight Marv was peak human strength close to superhuman and a smart fighter with great damage soak. I would say toss up in hand to hand

Marv. Predator has height and reach but Marv is stronger and more durable imo.

He has strength as well holding the Queen Alien with that chain.

Marv dies

/the end

Scar has the advantage in all categories except maybe damage soak. As much as I hate AvP and as much as I love Sin City I'll have to say Scar wins.