Help me find the thread

For some reason, no matter how hard I search, not matter the parameters, I cant find the thread with the prophecy on the Witch King, anybody able to help me find it?

I have been meaning to re-read like, every book available to me and any on here, and there are multiple uses for it.

I'm not sure whether there is such a thread. What should it contain?

If you're just searching for the words of the prophecy Glorfindel made to Earnur (as found in appendix A):

He will not return to this land. Far off yet is his doom, and not by the hand of man will he fall.

I could have sworn that it was this forum that had the debate on that prophecy. I read a massive thread about it somewhere, but it should be here.

Its just a debate on the meaning of that prophecy itself, whether NO man could kill him, whether a man COULD kill him, or whether it would take a woman to kill him.

As far as I read it, this is a prophecy about what will happen, not a limitation about what can happen (although from the Witch King's practical point of view, the first somewhat implies the latter).

So I think while any man (male human) could kill him, no man will (or as we see, does).

Yeah, I remember that discussion, it was on here some time. Sorry, I don't know where it went...

I'm not entirely sure which thread you mean, but I remember 2 threads which I have put below, which may include what you are looking for:

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=323597&highlight=Prophecy+forumid%3A34

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=511194&pagenumber=2

I think the last thread I have put is your best bet. The discussion of the Witch-King and the 'prophecy' gets going on page 3. Hope I've helped!