Barker:
It's a very cool sig, and I approve of the use of two of the renders I gave. The background I don't like as much and it feels like it's not all perfectly going together.
Thoren:
I really like the background in this one, looks great. And I think the spaceship is a nice addition. I like having a clearer view of the planet. But what's with the writing, why is there some writing in space? On top of it, you can't even read it.
Disregarding everything I said earlier, I'll just decide by gut-feeling, like a very bad cop might do, and give it to Thoren.
Congratulations, you win nothing...