Re: Who can Replicate Superman pulling 1/3 earth feat
Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
Who does it
These guys try solo to pull the earth unless there teamed up
Everyone gets flight and that magic chain1. WWH
2. Thor & Hercules
3. Namor Colossus Thing She Hulk Rhino Luke Cage (all normal version)
4. Classic Juggernaut - gets a ground to walk on with the chain hook to his back ( remember his near infinit momentum)
5. World Breaker
6. Captain Marvel & Black Adam
7. Thanos
8. Magneto
1. I think he could do it based on Hulk's feats of strength, which, generally, confirm him to be a peer or equal to Superman. The fact that he might not do it at first would probably only make him get angry enough to achieve the strength needed to do so, which is arguable he even needs to amp in order to do it.
2. Thor and Hercules definitely do it together as a team. And imo, either of them could do it under their own power.
3. Probably not, no.
4. Possibly.
5. Yeah.
6. They definitely do it together as a team. And either can do it on their own.
7. Probably, yes.
8. I doubt it.
Originally posted by carver9
Gladiator could have moved that planet by himself.
Damn dude, you should seriously stop that.
I know, that I praise Sentry a lot and always talk about his potential do solo the entire world, but I always have scans, to back my opinion up, while you didn't do crap for Gladiator in the most recent Gladiator threads.
Telling that he can defeat person XYZ and that he can acomplish the feat XYZ isn't going to help you out, if the people constantly ask you for proofs, yet you fail to do anything.
Re: Re: Who can Replicate Superman pulling 1/3 earth feat
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
1. I think he could do it based on Hulk's feats of strength, which, generally, confirm him to be a peer or equal to Superman. The fact that he might not do it at first would probably only make him get angry enough to achieve the strength needed to do so, which is arguable he even needs to amp in order to do it.2. Thor and Hercules definitely do it together as a team. And imo, either of them could do it under their own power.
3. Probably not, no.
4. Possibly.
5. Yeah.
6. They definitely do it together as a team. And either can do it on their own.
7. Probably, yes.
8. I doubt it.
I agree with all that, but I think Hulk can do it right away.
Originally posted by Enzeru
I think it's even worse that people are always calling out the 1/3 of the weight, just because there were three people pulling the Earth, so now everyone things that these three characters are perfectly equal in terms of strenght, when it comes to that weird feat.
Yes, but to be fair you also can't disprove that they weren't all each pulling an equal share. There is no way to say definitively one way or another.
It also doesn't prove that they are equals in strength, although it does show that they are in the same general class imo.
For example, you could argue that they were all pulling 1/3, but that Superman didn't need to use all of his strength whereas the other two did. You could argue that Superman pulled more than the other two because he is stronger. You could even say that WW pulled more because she was exerting more effort, where as Superman pulled less not because he's weaker but because he wasn't trying as hard. I'm obviously making these up, but you can't prove or disprove any of them based on the panel.
In the end, I think it is a great strength feat for all of them and that is where you have to leave it.
As for the thread, all of them could do it except #3 and maybe Mags.
Originally posted by Sasaraixx
Yes, but to be fair you also can't disprove that they weren't all each pulling an equal share. There is no way to say definitively one way or another.It also doesn't prove that they are equals in strength, although it does show that they are in the same general class imo.
For example, you could argue that they were all pulling 1/3, but that Superman didn't need to use all of his strength whereas the other two did. You could argue that Superman pulled more than the other two because he is stronger. You could even say that WW pulled more because she was exerting more effort, where as Superman pulled less not because he's weaker but because he wasn't trying as hard. I'm obviously making these up, but you can't prove or disprove any of them based on the panel.
In the end, I think it is a great strength feat for all of them and that is where you have to leave it.
As for the thread, all of them could do it except #3 and maybe Mags.
Originally posted by abhilegend
They were certainly not pulling same weight. Time and time again it's been proved that neither diana nor j'onn come close to superman in strength. Only hardcore WW fans likes to think that diana is "almost equal" in strength to him. It was more like 40/31/29 as in superman/diana/j'onn.
It's been proven time and time again that Wonder Woman and Jon are peers to.Superman physically.
Originally posted by Bouboumaster
Didn't he broke a planet by punching it? I don't know much of Gladiator, but I think he did it...
He did; no-one denies that. It's in the quantification that things get iffy.
Originally posted by carver9
He moved objects that blocked an entire starlane by himself. Yes, he can move a planet.
Funny how he gets the benefit of the doubt when others don't.
Originally posted by carver9
Naah...equals imo.
You'd be wrong, then. And the comics agree that you're wrong.