Who would look better?

Who would shine the most against HP Doomsday? Give him the best fight of his life WITHOUT resorting to bfring?

Superman (Superman has the most experience fighting against Doomsday...let's take that away. This is a first time meeting of the two).

Thor

Silver Surfer

World War Hulk

Who would show the best performance against HP Doomsday and last the longest?

Hulk does the worst by far.

Depends how Thor/Surfer fight DD.

Originally posted by carver9
Who would shine the most against HP Doomsday? Give him the best fight of his life WITHOUT resorting to bfring?

Superman (Superman has the most experience fighting against Doomsday...let's take that away. This is a first time meeting of the two).

Thor

Silver Surfer

World War Hulk

Who would show the best performance against HP Doomsday and last the longest?

But from your list I'd say SS does best.

Originally posted by Nihilist
Hulk does the worst by far.

Depends how Thor/Surfer fight DD.

Got to be Thor and Surfer as they have abilities that presumably haven't killed HP DD before.

I say SS or Tbor but if its a fist to fist than WWH

Hulk's my choice. At this point he can reach and surpass Doomsday physically. Superman/Thor will almost certainly try and engage him close combat. They won't be able to win in such a situation without going out of their regular routine like dropping mental blocks, versatility usage etc.

Surfer would probably get his ass handed to him the worst the first go around.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Hulk's my choice. At this point he can reach and surpass Doomsday physically. Superman/Thor will almost certainly try and engage him close combat. They won't be able to win in such a situation without going out of their regular routine like dropping mental blocks, versatility usage etc.

Surfer would probably get his ass handed to him the worst the first go around.

This is what I was thinking.

Hulk would last the longest imo. A fist fight between those 2 should virtually be a stalemate. Thor has the potential to do the best depending on how he chooses to fight. Surfer probably does the worst, b/c I don't see him being able to mix it up h2h at all.

I'm going with Thor he can get in and exchange up close and if that don't work he can pull out the exotic powers. In a straight up fist fight got to go with Hulk.

Superman dies again.

Hulk does well.
Surfer could theoretically use his power set to figure out the genetic mutation in doomsday and neutralize his powers... assuming there is a way... Create a plague like what killed lobos people... Slice him in half with his surfer board going at hyperspace speeds like exiles surfer... Etc...
But due to his character he'd never resort to that kind of stuff and gets killed...

Thor with his belt etc kills without he struggles but wins.

Just out of curiosity, when's the last time someone who couldn't counter surfer's exotic abilities (basically a brick) put him down? Far as I can remember that hasn't happened recently outside of that rulk garbage.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Hulk's my choice. At this point he can reach and surpass Doomsday physically. Superman/Thor will almost certainly try and engage him close combat. They won't be able to win in such a situation without going out of their regular routine like dropping mental blocks, versatility usage etc.

Surfer would probably get his ass handed to him the worst the first go around.

👆

Superman imo.

Originally posted by JayDaDon
Just out of curiosity, when's the last time someone who couldn't counter surfer's exotic abilities (basically a brick) put him down? Far as I can remember that hasn't happened recently outside of that rulk garbage.

Thanos punched his lights out using no other powers. Lunatik gave him a bit of a beating too [long time ago]

Originally posted by -Pr-
Superman imo dies

Superman hate huh?

Originally posted by rotiart
Superman hate huh?

You wrote it. shrug

Originally posted by -Pr-
You wrote it. shrug

:-P

Originally posted by Scoobless
Thanos punched his lights out using no other powers. Lunatik gave him a bit of a beating too [long time ago]

Yeah but they made it clear thanos plain trumps surfer. Also doesn't thanos also have matter/energy manip? I'll have to check out that lunatic fight tho...

Probably God Hulk, tbh.

Barring Pak's monster, Thor, imo.

Hulk would get the holy crap beat out of him ( but he survived holes punched straight through him by zom so he wont die) and then he would eventually reach and surpass doomsday and win at his own game, ( adapting to become more powerful than doomsday)