Lord Lucien
Lets all love Lain
Originally posted by Nephthys
I liked Marek in the 1st game. He wasn't that bad for a video game character. I liked that he had a clearly defined arc that made him grow into a better person eventually sacrificing himself for a cause greater than himself. He's no more bland than Luke was in ANH imo (dont quote me on this)I mean, he's got more of a defined personality than someone like Revan or Jaden but no-one gives those games shit for having 'bad' protagonists.
I don't know about Jaden (I've not played Jedi Academy), but KotOR isn't good because
Revan's interesting, it's because everyone
else is interesting. I don't play that game for its silent protagonist, I play for Canderous, Jolee, Malak, Yuthura etc. That and the interesting story--the gameplay itself is noticeable aging, but still entirely tolerable.
But I only play The Force Unleashed for the gameplay--which is fine. It's also the only reason I play Call of Duty. But I've never confused my appreciation of the gameplay with the story or characters. They're very bland and forgettable (decaduply so for the sequel). Luke at least had something to him--people b*tch that he was "annoying" or "whiny", but he was supposed to be; he was a kid and an inexperienced newbie. If he was calm, straight-faced, or tough from the get-go, his character would be unbelievable and boring. The OT's style of storytelling necessitates a fresh-faced green-horn so that we can mark his growth and accomplishments. Marek and Anakin Skywalker (AotC onward) are already trained, disciplined, and experienced when they're introduced--but combine that with their youth and ostensible (and frankly never-seen) "growth" throughout their stories, and it makes for an unrelatable/unlikeable/uninteresting character. They both had the potential to be otherwise, but their respective developers obviously couldn't be bothered.
F*ck sake, apparently the notion of a concise reply is beyond me.