DarkSaint85
Bonified abstract
Aquaman wins. Unfortunately for Hawkman, following the unveiling of the Claw of Horus, I'm assuming most (if not all) of the core members know of its capabilities. He sucker-punched Superman, that won't happen here.
Aquaman summons a weird Elder God thing, which eats Hawkman.
OR
You've seen how the Deathstroke/Hawkman fight went down in Identity crisis? Yeah, that's what's happening here. Orin leaps into the air, rips the harness off him, Hawkman crashes to the ground and Aquaman stamps on his head. Being denser than a human, and falling from a great height, would cave his head in.
I like Hawkman AND Aquaman. I don't like blatant attempts at spite threads (note, this isn't a spite thread, only an attempt). Although, saying that, even after crippling Aquaman and handing every advantage to Hawkman, he still only gives Hawkman 7/10, so not QUITE a spite thread attempt, I guess.