Originally posted by biensalsa
I was unable to edit in time I wanted my last post to be:That sounds to me like busting a dark dimension = to earth busting?
Or are you trying to say Hulk will have busted THIS dimension too?
Naah, I'm not saying that but I do think he could wreck earth and probably nearby planets if he was to go all out and Strange believed it as well. It was always mentioned that Hulk could lay waste to a planet if he went all out...this was mentioned when he was on planet Sakaar...he just had freedom to do it in the Dark Dimension because Betty couldn't get hurt from his attacks or anything else that happened.
When Betty wished herself to be Hulks equal, he had the ability to cut lose without endangering or hurting her (even after the planet and moon destruction). All stated on panel.
http://i1099.photobucket.com/albums/g386/psychogundam1/hulk10.jpg
Originally posted by carver9
Naah, I'm not saying that but I do think he could wreck earth and probably nearby planets if he was to go all out and Strange believed it as well. It was always mentioned that Hulk could lay waste to a planet if he went all out...this was mentioned when he was on planet Sakaar...he just had freedom to do it in the Dark Dimension because Betty couldn't get hurt from his attacks or anything else that happened.When Betty wished herself to be Hulks equal, he had the ability to cut lose without endangering or hurting her (even after the planet and moon destruction). All stated on panel.
http://i1099.photobucket.com/albums/g386/psychogundam1/hulk10.jpg
No need, for scans I am a proud owner of it 🙂 , but thanks, the thought it is what it counts 😛
Thanos and Bor are both above those tiers, so yes they can do it, via punch? debatable, villains usually do not have those kind of feats to show
Originally posted by carver9Betty wishing to be Hulks equal had alot to do with the feat carver are you insane or something?
Naah, I'm not saying that but I do think he could wreck earth and probably nearby planets if he was to go all out and Strange believed it as well. It was always mentioned that Hulk could lay waste to a planet if he went all out...this was mentioned when he was on planet Sakaar...he just had freedom to do it in the Dark Dimension because Betty couldn't get hurt from his attacks or anything else that happened.When Betty wished herself to be Hulks equal, he had the ability to cut lose without endangering or hurting her (even after the planet and moon destruction). All stated on panel.
http://i1099.photobucket.com/albums/g386/psychogundam1/hulk10.jpg
Originally posted by carver9
Bring who back from death and why do you think they can do it?
OK, Some time now.
Why am I saying "bring back" from the dead?
Well as in many comics this is open to interpretation, but I do believe there is a clear intention on the writers part in here.
This is supposed to be an epic battle for the Hulk, the ultimate test, so He can finally cut loose, a great opposing force so He does not has to hold back and He is in danger to die, this is why He has to go all out, finally.
First reference to die:
Second
Third
Planet buster
Dying, burning and reforming
You'll suffer all that He does, fighting, burning and reforming for eternity
So many references to dying on Pak's part, that is actually leads me to believe this is what happened.
Specially here, It seems Hulk is reforming again.
Just remember the previous panel was this
and then We see Hulk reforming again and cutting loose because now He cannot endanger or kill the innocent or the woman He loves thanks to the wishing well, he finally has everything He desires.
But then again, like I said this is open to interpretation like in many comics.
I commented this with a few friends and they seem to agree with the writers intention and the panel statements.
Is there an interview with Pak about this issue where He actually talks about this?
Originally posted by biensalsa
OK, Some time now.Why am I saying "bring back" from the dead?
Well as in many comics this is open to interpretation, but I do believe there is a clear intention on the writers part in here.
This is supposed to be an epic battle for the Hulk, the ultimate test, so He can finally cut loose, a great opposing force so He does not has to hold back and He is in danger to die, this is why He has to go all out, finally.
First reference to die:
Second
Third
Planet buster
Dying, burning and reforming
You'll suffer all that He does, fighting, burning and reforming for eternity
So many references to dying on Pak's part, that is actually leads me to believe this is what happened.
Specially here, It seems Hulk is reforming again.
Just remember the previous panel was this
and then We see Hulk reforming again and cutting loose because now He cannot endanger or kill the innocent or the woman He loves thanks to the wishing well, he finally has everything He desires.
But then again, like I said this is open to interpretation like in many comics.
I commented this with a few friends and they seem to agree with the writers intention and the panel statements.
Is there an interview with Pak about this issue where He actually talks about this?
Let me clear this up for you. First, no where on panel was it shown that Hulk died, but it was shown that everyone else died. Let's get a close up look at what happened.
The blast is going off, everyone is dying, melting, the planet is exploding. Hulk and she Rulk is still 100% without a scratch.
http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/8901478/Incredible_Hulks_635_003.jpg.html
Same here, everyone is completely melting, planet is turning to dust...Hulk and She Rulk is still fighting,.100% without a scratch.
http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/8901484/Incredible_Hulks_635_005.jpg.html
This clears it up...everyone ask, "who wished us back... Umar states that it wasn't her, Cho states, "it wasn't her, it was the Hulk. The Hulk wished everyone back "after" the explosion while standing on the cliff. You see everyone melt except Hulk and she Rulk (and I'm pretty sure Umar survived the attack as well).
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/52/81615084.jpg/
Then we have this...Hulk is clearly going all out on She Rulk because he know that he can't hurt her...he know that she can weather what ever attack he can dish out. That was the main reason the wish was made for She Rulk, so that she can be his equal and survive his power (stated on panel).
Originally posted by carver9
Let me clear this up for you. First, no where on panel was it shown that Hulk died, but it was shown that everyone else died. Let's get a close up look at what happened.The blast is going off, everyone is dying, melting, the planet is exploding. Hulk and she Rulk is still 100% without a scratch.
http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/8901478/Incredible_Hulks_635_003.jpg.html
What, they punch each other and then we cut to strange saying stop, where is the scene where they survive?
Same here, everyone is completely melting, planet is turning to dust...Hulk and She Rulk is still fighting,.100% without a scratch.http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/8901484/Incredible_Hulks_635_005.jpg.html
Classic carver, doing more harm to one he supports. Bruce explicitly says that the magic would "resurrect everyone again to fight again and again". none
This clears it up...everyone ask, "who wished us back... Umar states that it wasn't her, Cho states, "it wasn't her, it was the Hulk. The Hulk wished everyone back "after" the explosion while standing on the cliff. You see everyone melt except Hulk and she Rulk (and I'm pretty sure Umar survived the attack as well).
How do you know he already didn't make the wish, you know when the planet was not destroyed?
Then we have this...Hulk is clearly going all out on She Rulk because he know that he can't hurt her...he know that she can weather what ever attack he can dish out. That was the main reason the wish was made for She Rulk, so that she can be his equal and survive his power (stated on panel).
ermm
Originally posted by carver9
Let me clear this up for you. First, no where on panel was it shown that Hulk died, but it was shown that everyone else died. Let's get a close up look at what happened.The blast is going off, everyone is dying, melting, the planet is exploding. Hulk and she Rulk is still 100% without a scratch.
http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/8901478/Incredible_Hulks_635_003.jpg.html
Same here, everyone is completely melting, planet is turning to dust...Hulk and She Rulk is still fighting,.100% without a scratch.
http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/8901484/Incredible_Hulks_635_005.jpg.html
This clears it up...everyone ask, "who wished us back... Umar states that it wasn't her, Cho states, "it wasn't her, it was the Hulk. The Hulk wished everyone back "after" the explosion while standing on the cliff. You see everyone melt except Hulk and she Rulk (and I'm pretty sure Umar survived the attack as well).
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/52/81615084.jpg/
Then we have this...Hulk is clearly going all out on She Rulk because he know that he can't hurt her...he know that she can weather what ever attack he can dish out. That was the main reason the wish was made for She Rulk, so that she can be his equal and survive his power (stated on panel).
First two scans time is stopped.
Third scan is the one open to interpretation, You think Hulk is standing at the cliff after the "planet buster punch" and I will quote it as "planet buster punch" because is a "planet" under the physical laws of the dark dimension. I think Hulk is reforming because I see no where Betty Ross around who is supposed to have the same power level. And the lines going towards Hulk give me the impression of reformation. Like a "rewind" effect.
Plus you completely disregard the Writers many mentions of dying
Originally posted by carver9
Good try though.
Thanks, but, I'm not even trying yet. And believe me, this is why I said, this is OPEN to interpretation.
