Originally posted by quanchi112
Countdown already made new earth and earth one canon for the same character. It referenced it. You putting up wiki links don't prove anything as we have a dc comic in continuity already seal your doom.
So ignoring facts and continuing to rant, typical Quanchi. Oh well.
Originally posted by CogitoIt showed new earth as earth one superman. You're clearly wrong.
Countdown was recounting prior events. It was not establishing Earth One and New Earth as the same.It doesn't matter anyways. Both New Earth and Pre-Crisis Superman would win here, one is just more of a stomp than the other.
Wait, now you're trying to argue that Post-Crisis Superman is Pre-Crisis Superman?
If you're saying that Post-Crisis Superman has a history with Earth 2 Superman, even though Superman didn't meet Earth 2 Superman until IC, then you must mean that Pre and Post Crisis Superman are the same, which is a ridiculous assertion even for you.
Originally posted by CogitoTheir power levels aren't the same. Obviously. Just like Kal-L's power levels aren't the same post coie.
Wait, now you're trying to argue that Post-Crisis Superman is Pre-Crisis Superman?If you're saying that Post-Crisis Superman has a history with Earth 2 Superman, even though Superman didn't meet Earth 2 Superman until IC, then you must mean that Pre and Post Crisis Superman are the same, which is a ridiculous assertion even for you.
So you are claiming that Pre and Post Crisis Superman are the same, except there was some weird unexplained depowering/alteration of power (unexplained because you're writing off the explanation that's been in place for over twenty five years and that has been verified on panel god knows how many times in that period.)
😐
Originally posted by CogitoAll precrisis characters were more powerful than post crisis regardless if the crisis affected them or not. Think cog.
So you are claiming that Pre and Post Crisis Superman are the same, except there was some weird unexplained depowering/alteration of power (unexplained because you're writing off the explanation that's been in place for over twenty five years and that has been verified on panel god knows how many times in that period.)😐