DC's Underrated vs. Marvel's Underated

Orion
Sodom Yat
Firestorm
Captain Atom
Captain Comet
Cyborg

Vs

Nova
Firelord
Vulcan
Super Skrull
Skaar
Ikaris

No BFR

Fight on a deserted earth

Who wins?

You forgot to put Gladiator on your underated list.

Originally posted by carver9
You forgot to put Gladiator on your underated list.

Gladiator can be underrated or overrated depending on who you ask.

Swap out Blackbolt with Firelord. BB is not underrated on kmc, not by a long shot.

Originally posted by janus77
Swap out Blackbolt with Firelord. BB is not underrated on kmc, not by a long shot.

Good point

Either Captain Atom - Vulcan is an awesome fight or CA stomps and I have hugely overrated Vulcan ... my knowledge of CA is sketchy at best.

This team battle would be a fantastic read, imo ✅.

I'm not quite sure if SS and Ikaris can handle their DC counterparts. I'm inclined to favour DC by say 6-4.

Team 1, relatively easily.

Team 2.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Team 2.

Based on?

Originally posted by janus77
Either Captain Atom - Vulcan is an awesome fight or CA stomps and I have hugely overrated Vulcan ... my knowledge of CA is sketchy at best.

This team battle would be a fantastic read, imo ✅.

I'm not quite sure if SS and Ikaris can handle their DC counterparts. I'm inclined to favour DC by say 6-4.

Where do you see SS & Ike being considerably outclassed?

Originally posted by byrdgang21
Where do you see SS & Ike being considerably outclassed?

Orion - Nova: Orion, but close.
Sodom Yat - FireLord: undecided/maybe FL.
Firestorm - Vulcan: draw/Vulcan possibly.
Captain Atom - SS: CA pretty solidly, imo.
Captain Comet - Skaar: dunno.
Cyborg - Ikaris: Cyborg imo.

Originally posted by Cogito
Based on?