The Comedian Vs Bane

Started by Golgo135 pages

The Comedian Vs Bane

Movie versions!

vs

The Comedian. Stronger, faster and tougher.

bane.

really? I recall Comedian being superhumanly strong, punching out chunks of concrete, during his fight with Ozy, as well as having superspeed and accuracy too.

Bane was strong, but not quite a match for Comedian, imo.

bane was taking chunks out of a concrete pillar (damn near caved the thing in), and he was [a lot] more skilled than batman, who was [a lot] more skilled than a group of ra's' hand-ninjas, who were among the best fighters in the world.

imo, the comedian wasn't quite on bane's level.

I think its a great matchup.

Originally posted by janus77
really? I recall Comedian being superhumanly strong, punching out chunks of concrete, during his fight with Ozy, as well as having superspeed and accuracy too.

Bane was strong, but not quite a match for Comedian, imo.


Just checked the fight Comedian punched a very little piece of a wall off then he punched through some wood.
Bane left a huge hole in that pillar he wins easily.

I would say Bane. The Comedian may get a few good hits in but that may be it.

hmm, I thought the Comedian's demolition job on the apartment walls, whilst fighting Ozy showed a lot more strength. Bane did tear a chunk out of a pillar, but that's about it, iirc. And Bane was eventually matched by Batman.

Bane was more peak (movie/comic) human, whereas The Comedian was shown as being somewhat superhuman.

Remember Batman's been out of commission for 8yrs, he's nothing like as fit and capable as he was in his prime, so Bane's performances against him have to be judged accordingly. Batman's body is not in good nick, as the doctor establishes early on.

Originally posted by Estacado
Just checked the fight Comedian punched a very little piece of a wall off then he punched through some wood.
Bane left a huge hole in that pillar he wins easily.

hmm, I'll have to re-watch that fight scene, I remember him punching through the wall, with one of his wild swings.

Originally posted by janus77
hmm, I thought the Comedian's demolition job on the apartment walls, whilst fighting Ozy showed a lot more strength. Bane did tear a chunk out of a pillar, but that's about it, iirc. And Bane was eventually matched by Batman.

Bane was more peak (movie/comic) human, whereas The Comedian was shown as being somewhat superhuman.

Remember Batman's been out of commission for 8yrs, he's nothing like as fit and capable as he was in his prime, so Bane's performances against him have to be judged accordingly. Batman's body is not in good nick, as the doctor establishes early on.


Check the fight again Comedian barely did anything mentionable...

Originally posted by janus77
hmm, I'll have to re-watch that fight scene, I remember him punching through the wall, with one of his wild swings.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i3e_uWFfzeU

ok, I was wrong, he punches through a wooden partition not concrete.

Bane wins this.

Originally posted by janus77
hmm, I thought the Comedian's demolition job on the apartment walls, whilst fighting Ozy showed a lot more strength. Bane did tear a chunk out of a pillar, but that's about it, iirc. And Bane was eventually matched by Batman.

Bane was more peak (movie/comic) human, whereas The Comedian was shown as being somewhat superhuman.

Remember Batman's been out of commission for 8yrs, he's nothing like as fit and capable as he was in his prime, so Bane's performances against him have to be judged accordingly. Batman's body is not in good nick, as the doctor establishes early on.

batman never matched bane's skill. ever. even in round two, after batman's 'rocky-esque' comeback, bane was still picking him apart. all batman ended up doing is exploiting a weakness of bane's-- a weakness that i greatly doubt comedian would try to exploit, considering batman (with his great tactical knowledge) never attempted to do so during round one.

as far as batman's battle-worn body hindering him: his leg/knee is what was holding him back the most, and that was fixed early on after bruce donned the 'robo-brace' fox made for him and kicked through a brick wall.

Originally posted by janus77
ok, I was wrong, he punches through a wooden partition not concrete.

Wasn't even wood. It was drywall

Bane.

Doesn't the Comedian use...you know...guns?

Comedian should win.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Doesn't the Comedian use...you know...guns?

Comedian should win.

Bane uses nukes.

The comedian was going up against Ozy(who would stomp Bane) and putting up a fight will not at his prime.
Prime Comedian would walk all over Bane

Originally posted by SasuOna
The comedian was going up against Ozy(who would stomp Bane) and putting up a fight will not at his prime.
Prime Comedian would walk all over Bane
No proof Ozy would stomp Bane. And Comedian got his ass kicked by Ozy. But Comedian still wins this fight.