The Butcher vs Steven Seagal

The Butcher, Mahogany from Midnight Meat Train

vs

Steven Seagal ( Mason ) from Hard To Kill

Mason is on the train unarmed and Mahogany does not have his sickness.

I'm pretty sure Butcher had Super Strength/Durability.

I'm going with the Butcher. Mason wouldn't know what hit him.

Mason becomes food for the creatures.

Seagal gets his arm ripped off while making a stupid face and trying some aikido move.

Clive Barker ftw!