Thor, Silver Surfer, Ironman(Extremis) vs Superman, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern(Hal)

Which team takes this? Marvel or DC

Supes over Thor
Hal would be a better match for Surfer... probably stalemate for a while if it's Hal from his solo book

WW over IM

ends up 3 on 1 and they beat Surfer

Good fight though.

Preboot?

Either way for Thor and Superman. If I had to pick though Thor will win the majority.

Surfer can handle wondy.

Ironman gets worked by Hal.

So it's an exhausted Thor and relatively healthy Surfer vs what should be an A ok Hal.

Team 1 for the slight majority.

Team 2 for a slight majority. And no, surfer can't beat diana easily.

Team 2

THor or Surfer is a good match for any 1 on team 2

But Iron man would get owned by any of the 3 on the other team

Man why have people been putting Iron man in the high herald range

Originally posted by abhilegend
Team 2 for a slight majority. And no, surfer can't beat diana easily.

Surfer would have an easier time versus supes, Thor could beat GL, and ironman has the ability to stall Diana for a while

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Agreed

Surfer would have an easier time versus supes, Thor could beat GL, and ironman has the ability to stall Diana for a while

Surfer takes out supes
Thor takes out wonder Woman
And like in every thread people act like ironman is a pushover. Tony can at least hold off hal until surfer or thor win their fights.

Marvel 8/10

Team DC.

Originally posted by DarkOdin
Team 2

THor or Surfer is a good match for any 1 on team 2

But Iron man would get owned by any of the 3 on the other team

Man why have people been putting Iron man in the high herald range

Thats his respect thread. Take a look sometime, hes actually pretty impressive.
Especially his current suit. And hes only getting better.

Iron Man isn't High Herald.

He's consistently High Meta (about as high as you can get, imo) with Low Herald showings, though.

Dunno where the "thor can take supes" argument came from......

Supes clearly stomps Thor.

WW beats IM... she's not gonna stand there and let him fire at her.. one lasso and she's got a plaything to swing around.

Hal and Surfer is the most interesting potential fight.

Originally posted by ColossusGrundy
Dunno where the "thor can take supes" argument came from......

Supes clearly stomps Thor.

WW beats IM... she's not gonna stand there and let him fire at her.. one lasso and she's got a plaything to swing around.

Hal and Surfer is the most interesting potential fight.

Probably from feats and showings against foes of similar power level and what not.

It's feasible he'd get a majority on Thor, but a hard fought one. Not a "stomp" in any sense of the word.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Iron Man isn't High Herald.

He's consistently High Meta (about as high as you can get, imo) with Low Herald showings, though.

We should make a tier just for him... He does impressive shiet for a high meta.

let's call him himetalowrald

Team 2.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Probably from feats and showings against foes of similar power level and what not.

It's feasible he'd get a majority on Thor, but a hard fought one. Not a "stomp" in any sense of the word.

Happened before with JLA n Avengers... I would expect it again.

Originally posted by ColossusGrundy
Happened before with JLA n Avengers... I would expect it again.

Not sure how you can look at that fight and claim it was a stomp...?

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Not sure how you can look at that fight and claim it was a stomp...?

Watching Supes put up with thor until catching his hammer and walloping him to a KO.

That's a stomp, doesnt matter what happened after

Originally posted by ColossusGrundy
Watching Supes put up with thor until catching his hammer and walloping him to a KO.

That's a stomp, doesnt matter what happened after

In which Superman was clearly struggling and didn't do so easily and then proclaimed that Thor was one of the toughest single foes he'd faced.

How is that a one sided stomp? Quick answer is it's not, but I'm curious as to your reasoning.

I have no problem with people thinking Superman > Thor or even using Avengers/JLA as reasoning why, but it's clear that that fight - and crossover as a whole - portrayed them as peers in power and that such a fight is anything but a "stomp".

Not sure how people can read it and think anything otherwise, tbh.